NSW's Price Floor Trap and the 519 Proptech Myth

Episode 27 · Fri, 13 Nov 2026 · 1h 21m

This week on Before the Weekend, Kasey McDonald and Peter Schravemade work through the NSW pricing rules landing on Tuesday 17 November, a hard look at how many proptechs Australia really has, and a property management desk loaded with December deadlines. Peter is back from the National Association of REALTORS® conference in New Orleans, and the show opens on NSW. Stage two of the underquoting reforms goes live on Tuesday: no more "Contact Agent", a single price or a maximum 10% range on every ad, and a four-part price floor agents can't advertise beneath - the estimated selling price, the seller's minimum, the top registered bid at a passed-in auction, and any written offer rejected on price alone. Peter walks through three scenarios where nobody wins: the seller whose circumstances change mid-campaign, the non-binding passed-in bid that can be used to pin a property above the market, and the comps window that locks agents into peak-era prices in a falling Sydney market. Kasey picks up Leanne Pilkington's question of how a replacement agent is meant to know what was rejected under the first one, and the pair ask whether NSW negotiations are about to move off email and back to the phone. Then Peter calls BS on the "519 proptechs" figure. With 600+ companies already tracked and 70-80 new ones surfacing in the latest accelerator intake, he puts the real number at 700-800 - driven by tools property managers and agencies are now building themselves. Kasey explains why offices are coding their own fixes for twelve tools that don't talk to each other. They also unpack Craig Deveson's audit of 38,000 agents (Properti is a REACH portfolio company), where the average agent scored 46/100 for AI visibility, and why faceless PM profiles are costing relationships. On agency models: why fewer top billers want to be licensee-in-charge, David Highland's equity partnership approach, YPA's agent-to-owner pathway, and the hard question of how you pay out equity when a salesperson leaves. On the property management desk: does it really take 20 steps to fix a leaking tap? Kasey says it starts with setting expectations at the start of a tenancy, and shares how to use AI to surface maintenance data for weekly PM meetings. Plus Victoria's 1 December blind cord deadline, the 10 December Privacy Act disclosure rules for agencies turning over $3M+, principals panic-buying rent rolls without fixing operations first, and the buyer's agent hangover in Geelong, Logan and Perth, where investors were promised rents the local market won't pay. Kasey closes the desk with Victorian data on the gap between rents and repayments, and why PMs need to be on the phone to owners now. In The Blotter: real estate named the ATO's second most targeted industry, with 76% of hit businesses turning over under $2M; the top AUSTRAC mistake around beneficial owners of trusts and companies; a $20,000 fine for a Victorian housing provider whose lease clauses gave it unlimited access to tenants' homes; outgoing inspections after DFV vacates; a WA buyer who lost almost $200,000 to an intercepted settlement email, and why every office needs a call-to-verify policy; the Anthony Di Nardo case moving from Newcastle to Sydney; and ASIC's investigation into the $3.4B Bathla Group collapse. Friday Feel Good: Matthew Farrugia cold-called Tim Andrews' signboard as a 19-year-old asking for a start. Fifteen years and a five-year succession plan later, he owns LJ Hooker Terrigal. Got a view on the NSW changes as they roll out? Email hello@beforetheweekend.com.

Full transcript

**Kasey McDonald** (00:07)

Happy Friday, the thirteenth of November, and we're up to episode twenty seven on before the weekend. Can you believe that we are in the middle of November? Pete Schravemade.

**Peter Schravemade** (00:20)

No, I can't. I didn't think about it until you just mentioned it.

**Kasey McDonald** (00:21)

Ha ha ha

**Peter Schravemade** (00:22)

Then I was trying to hide it. But all the cr I got back here and there are Christmas decorations everywhere. So

**Kasey McDonald** (00:27)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (00:28)

I figure like it's it's not not long yet. I suppose it's only one month and and two weeks until until the fat man's coming down the chimney. So uh if you've got a chimney, well who am I who am I joking? Unless you're in Victoria, Tasmania, maybe you've got a chimney. I

**Kasey McDonald** (00:36)

Yes. Yes. You I know. Where are you living? Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (00:45)

used to have one at the old house, but there's no way a fat guy would fit down there.

Anyway, hopefully you're

**Kasey McDonald** (00:49)

Did you give it a try?

**Peter Schravemade** (00:53)

I see what you've done with that. Hopefully none of your kids are listening. So spoiler alert. What have you been up to this week? What's been happening?

**Kasey McDonald** (00:59)

Yeah. um,

really great week actually. Um, been in Queensland, so I've been kind of grounded here in the state, but being out and about uh on the ground with customers as well and just, you know, I got I guess hearing what they've been experiencing uh in our in our property market, which as we know it it's not super exciting. like well, I'm

**Peter Schravemade** (01:23)

Well, depends on who

you are.

**Kasey McDonald** (01:25)

Yeah, I guess. But um yeah, I know I think everyone's just really trying to get through the rest of the year, if if I can say. But now they're really taking a really good look under the hood in their business. And it's certainly what I've been encouraging as I've been chatting to them. Um so yeah. How was um how was the States?

**Peter Schravemade** (01:42)

Yeah, it was big. I mean, I I really like it. I I liked New Orleans. Um, and I was over there not just for the the place, although if you look at my social media, that's look looks like what it was.

**Kasey McDonald** (01:51)

Mm-hmm. uh

**Peter Schravemade** (01:53)

Um, but yeah, there were there was obviously there was a a large Realtors event, the National Association of REALTORS® event goes on and we we crossed live from that, or at least from Bourbon Street last week. But yeah, look, it was it was a good conference and numbers are down, um even over there. So

they they didn't have as many people as I had. I I've got to say the exhibit hall was a bit lackluster. I obviously, with the exception of our phenomenal REACH booth, I probably

**Kasey McDonald** (02:21)

Ha ha ha.

**Peter Schravemade** (02:21)

have to probably have to put that in, but in genuine, like being very, very serious about it. Um it was it was the the large largely the where all the innovation was um at that show, a lot of the technology I'd seen before or in a different format. So

I don't know that I've got a lot to uh report from there. Content wise, I I

**Kasey McDonald** (02:42)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (02:42)

actually think um I actually think we have a bit of an edge over the Americans at the moment. We the

**Kasey McDonald** (02:47)

Great.

**Peter Schravemade** (02:48)

what the way that we're talking about technology is more forward thinking than than where it where they're at. And obviously a large part of that event, they're the legislative body. So um, you know, I'm not gonna make comment about how their legislation differs

**Kasey McDonald** (03:01)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (03:01)

from ours. It's it's it's chalk and cheese. they don't use that actually. They've never heard of that analogy.

**Kasey McDonald** (03:06)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (03:07)

But it's they say it's night and day. Yeah, it's it's just a totally different ball game. But I did have Antonia uh traveling over there as well. Well, I didn't have her there, she was there, but um I you know I I had the privilege of introducing her to a lot of the contacts that I've met through my time at BoxBrownie and where I am now, and and that was really great. I think the the there's a lot to be said um at any conference about human connection and the networks that you form as part of that

**Kasey McDonald** (03:33)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (03:33)

so.

That'll be really good. And and you know, there was a couple of things we I was looking at over there for um the REIQ LIFT conference, which is coming up later in the in next year. So um yeah, pretty excited about uh about a few of those things. But I I could tell you, but I'd have to kill you kind of thing. So that's not a secrecy. Um but it's good, it's good to be back in Australia drinking

**Kasey McDonald** (03:54)

Yep.

**Peter Schravemade** (03:55)

fantastic coffee. And um it's like, you know that coffee void when you go over there, they have the worst coffee in the world.

**Kasey McDonald** (04:00)

Yeah. That's coffee they

do.

**Peter Schravemade** (04:03)

And you can't say anything

because they think it's amazing. And you're like, you know, they they refer to as coffee. And you're like going, it's not even that. Like I it's dirty black water. Yeah. Yay. Like what? Please let me line up for 40 minutes. So the lady at the counter. Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (04:10)

Yeah. When they say they're like, let's go to Starbucks, like it's a really exciting thing, right? And you're like, Woo, yeah. And and you're in the what are they cat the canisters and they just what's the

what are they called? Those coffee things that you have at the um at the soccer or the like, yeah, though and they just press the button at the top and you get like coffee out. Yeah. uh

**Peter Schravemade** (04:25)

D the drip filters. It's like Burko. Yeah, it's not quite. They d they do actually drip filter them, but it's not

quite the the instant coffee, but it may as well be. I look, we're just snobs. And that's the way they treat us.

**Kasey McDonald** (04:37)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (04:39)

They were treating me like I was a snob for wanting good coffee. I don't know. I got back here,

**Kasey McDonald** (04:42)

oh

**Peter Schravemade** (04:43)

Ebony and I got back here yesterday and we had a coffee and it was like, oh my gosh, where was this for

**Kasey McDonald** (04:47)

Ha ha ha.

**Peter Schravemade** (04:49)

two weeks? So um good to be back in Australia. Headed to Perth tomorrow.

For um a Tech Fest, which is a conference that

**Kasey McDonald** (04:56)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (04:57)

we put on over there. It's just a small conference. But hey, if you're in Perth and you're keen, I'd love to catch up with you. It's going to be run out of Mandra. I think I've said that correctly. Not Mandura, Mandra. So well, if you're in the if you're in the vicinity, I'd love to catch up with you next week. Just reach out. um What else?

**Kasey McDonald** (05:13)

Awesome. What have we got on today's show?

**Peter Schravemade** (05:16)

Yeah, we've got quite a bit actually, but I think the major focus is some new laws that are coming to New South Wales.

**Kasey McDonald** (05:22)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:22)

Um,

which gives Victoria a break for a while. Because

**Kasey McDonald** (05:24)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:26)

I mean they've they've had it. Um, although interestingly, I've been watching the the fed the the state politics down in Victoria, and it

**Kasey McDonald** (05:33)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:34)

does seem as though um the Labour government has is finally there's something switched there. I it looks as though, judging from the polls, not that you can believe them, like what the polls are any an indicator, but it certainly seems like the voting public has turned on Labour at the moment and

you know, I I I'm I'd I don't care. Red, blue, orange, green, whichever you vote, it just it seems like Victoria needs a change. That's where I'm at. Like if I'm honest, it just seems that way. It just I can't, I can't get over some of the stuff that's happened down there. And I don't know how I would feel if I was a Victorian. But um, every Victorian I speak to.

**Kasey McDonald** (06:10)

New South Wales might be

heading in the same path, maybe, from what I'm uh reading here. I know.

**Peter Schravemade** (06:13)

They could they could, but it was such a great start by the Minns

government. How did we get to where we are at the moment? Well,

**Kasey McDonald** (06:20)

I know.

**Peter Schravemade** (06:21)

we should we should focus on that. So away from

**Kasey McDonald** (06:23)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (06:24)

federal politics and and um the Victorian market, I th I think the lead story this weekend, this is the by by sheer volume. Like um I obviously I think by numbers, I have more Queensland friends than the rest of the states. I have a lot of friends in New South Wales and Victoria. Uh this is not not a boast. I'm just

If if I was to divide my friends' groups down um just this week, the sheer amount of noise coming from my friends' social posts about the the changes to legislation that are coming in in four days. So for those of you who are unaware, you might be Queensland, Victorian, Tasmanian, Adelaide, wherever you are in Australia, on Tuesday the seventeenth, um, stage two of New South Wales property and stock agents amendment. Uh love the fact that the stock agents are still included in that, of course, um, because they they auction things.

**Kasey McDonald** (07:13)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (07:14)

It goes live, but it's built on top of stage one. Um penalties up to 110,000, three times the agent's commission, which is an interesting one.

**Kasey McDonald** (07:22)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (07:23)

plus there's a new thing the commission is power to force an agent to publicly advertise their own misconduct or pay for an independent value audit if he disagrees. That's a that's all controversial. So what the ban is is um it it's it's a price on inquiry or contact agent.

So um you've got it's a mandate that says you've got to have a single price or a or a maximum of 10% range on every ad except the physical signboard. And you need to impose a rigid four-pronged statutory price floor. And we'll talk a

**Kasey McDonald** (07:55)

Okay.

**Peter Schravemade** (07:56)

little bit about that. But the the things that are uh in there is that an agent cannot advertise bene below the estimated selling price. The two, the seller's minimum acceptance price, um, they can't advertise below that.

Three, they cannot advertise um the highest bid by a registered bidder at a passed in auction. They can't advertise under that. So we'll come to that. I know this is a lot. Um, or four, they cannot advertise below a written offer rejected only because the price was too low. So obviously Tim McKibbin, CEO of the REINSW, and I've been also watching uh Leanne Pilkington, who's never short of letting you know what she thinks. Um both of those are out there.

Um, there's zero mechanism for a change of circumstances in a falling market. And we're going to look at a little bit of what that what that means. But I I've prepared three scenarios I think that are really important. So I'll talk you through this. So uh scenario one, the seller whose life falls apart mid-campaigns, and and and we've got we've got unemployment later in this, and I haven't

**Kasey McDonald** (09:02)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (09:02)

even included that. So, you know, just flagging that straight up.

So imagine this week one, a buyer emails a full written offer of 1.5 stating price, deposit, settlement date, and conditions. Um, in New South Wales, unlike other registrations, um, it doesn't need to be an offer on a contract, Kasey. Can you get your head around that for a second?

**Kasey McDonald** (09:21)

Yes. Yep. Yep.

**Peter Schravemade** (09:23)

So in in Queensland, I would not call it an offer unless it was signed on a contract. But in New South Wales,

It is a it just has to be in writing. And in writing, as far as I understand that, that can be SMS, email, whatever. The vendor rejects it solely because they want 1.55. So the offers come in at 1.5. It's about you know, 50,000 under, or because they're looking at accepting a higher offer. Somebody might have bid it at 1.55. That 1.5 million rejection instantly locks in that price as the permanent permanent statutory flaw.

So there's no expiry, no sunset clause in the regulation. The the agent can no longer advertise that property under 1.5 for a property that's 1.55. So imagine this um weeks two to four, the contract's signed at 1.55. The vendor or the seller, let's go seller, receives a serious medical diagnosis like the ones uh this is actually happening. Um we spoke about Sam Dalby's scenario with his client

**Kasey McDonald** (10:25)

Mm-hmm. Yes, Sam's. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (10:28)

last week. let's say they they separate.

a life change happens, they get squeezed, they have to move. We talked about unemployment. Or here's the B. Um, what if

**Kasey McDonald** (10:39)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (10:39)

the building in pest uncovers $200,000 worth of termite or structural damage and they walk away? The seller now genuinely wants to go to the market beneath 1.5 million, let's say at 1.4. Um, and the agent has, you know, can genuinely see that now, given the circumstances, the revised price should be 1.4.

Yet they cannot legally be advertised beneath 1.5. So buyers searching up to 1.45 would never see it in a portal filter. Um, yeah. The the

**Kasey McDonald** (11:10)

Right.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:11)

buyers moved on weeks ago and the lit listing sits stale. Now, I I mean, did you understand that scenario? Does that make sense to you? Uh

**Kasey McDonald** (11:18)

Yes. Yeah it does.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:21)

I I thought the the job, you know, the I th I thought the intention of all of this was to pair buyers and sellers together.

**Kasey McDonald** (11:29)

Yes, yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:30)

But

clearly in that scenario, no one has won. The the seller hasn't won. The purchaser hasn't won. The agent hasn't won. Uh, there doesn't seem to be a winner in that scenario. Should we should we look at a another scenario?

**Kasey McDonald** (11:39)

No. Yeah. Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:42)

So this is a non-binding um passed in auction bid. Um, so I think I'm gonna call this a sabotage loophole. I think actually this is an interesting one. Uh the auction is on Saturday, the reserve is two point two million.

A registered bidder gets carried away and bids 2.1 million and the property passes in Monday morning because the property passed in without the hammer falling. That 2.1 bidder is not legally bound to that bid. On Monday morning, their finance falls over and they buy down the street or whatever reason they pull out. Um, under the law, 2.1 is now a permanent minimum advertised price for the rest of the campaign.

And the agent's got to update every online ad. And here's a here's another one that we haven't even spoken about. They're given less than 24 hours to update that on everything, like on everything.

**Kasey McDonald** (12:32)

Okay.

**Peter Schravemade** (12:33)

TikTok on you name it, they have to advertise that. So um on let's go. Um this, I I actually think people can weaponize this. I think um let's say a mate's rival agent's mate turns up or a neighbor or a tactical buyer's agent who knows the reserve is 2.2.

They can register a bit at 2.1, knowing it'll pass in and walk away, deliberately pinning the property above where the buyers are sitting. Do you get that? Do you do you understand that scenario as well?

**Kasey McDonald** (13:00)

Yes. Yep. Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (13:03)

Obviously, counterproductive again, no one sells. There's no winner in this. Um, and here's scenario three, the unusual home priced off Boom era comps. So

Um agents may must justify their sales price using three comparable sales. Most good agents do that within two kilometers

**Kasey McDonald** (13:20)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (13:20)

and six months in Metro New South Wales. Um, or it, you know, it can extend to 12 months if fewer than three exist. So there's some rules around that. Um, even in there's some rules around regional metro. So look look that side up. I'm not going to go over that for the sake of this. But a six-month metro window and an 18-month regional window capture peak.

era prices

**Kasey McDonald** (13:43)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (13:44)

and the mo you know the market no longer pays. And I think this has largely been the issue is that um fair fair trading thinks that um I what came up with this uh idea when the prices were going upwards, like on a on a rise. But in Sydney at the moment, for the third, fourth consecutive month, prices have been falling.

And so, you know, we're now looking at a scenario. Let I'll go back to this scenario three. There's a the the fair trading can order an independent value or audit an agent's estimate at the agent's expense. So the agent has to pay for that audit. Agents will defensively quote high off comps to avoid a $55,000, $110,000 fine. Every subsequent price drops drop requires revising the estimate, notifying the seller in writing, amending the agency agreement.

And updating every ad within one business day. Do you do you get that? Like they they you almost have to have it instantly audited every month. Send off information as part of it. So you know, this is where Leanne Pilkington flagged. If an agent sacks agent A, um, well, to to escape a 1.5 million rejected offer floor, how does incoming agent B verify what offers were rejected under agent A? How do they even know about that? Like,

What do you what do you think? Where do you think this is leading? Like this just seems stupid. It seems

**Kasey McDonald** (15:12)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (15:13)

absolutely ridiculous. And we've heard some clangers like the D V one four

**Kasey McDonald** (15:17)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (15:18)

tenants in in Victoria. I don't I just d I don't even know where I'd go with this.

**Kasey McDonald** (15:25)

Well, I think it's something that we've shared before is that we've got government now trying to um put prices, uh, I guess, on on what it is a buyer should be paying for property, is is my analogy on this. Is there they're

**Peter Schravemade** (15:39)

Yeah, well why not?

**Kasey McDonald** (15:40)

dictating uh in their own way, I I'm reading this as like they're they're dictating this because in all of those scenarios, not one person wins, and to Leanne's point,

How can Agent B, who's maybe coming in because Agent A wasn't able to get that result? And that result wasn't because Agent A actually didn't do um their role well, right? They've now been um bound by what would be these new legislations. So Agent B comes in. So how does Agent B provide evidence or justify what may have happened with Agent A to ensure that they're

**Peter Schravemade** (16:10)

I don't know.

**Kasey McDonald** (16:11)

like that's that's a big that's a definitely a big question. And I think Leanne's

**Peter Schravemade** (16:15)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (16:16)

right in absolutely flagging that, that it's been

totally misunderstood as to how this would we be w working in reality. Um and I just think that's unfortunately where our governments are just not getting that peace. We're we're not, they're not being effective in communicating with the REIs to actually understand what is truly happening on the ground. What is our role? Because that's just now taking our role away from us.

**Peter Schravemade** (16:42)

Yeah, I agree. I agree. And and um the the uh probably more than that. Like forget forget about us. I think the vendors or the sellers, the sellers that are really by the way, if you're listening to this for the first time, vendor and seller means the same thing. We in Queensland we call them vendors, but a vendor could be anything, it can be a street vendor, somebody selling anything. Um the the sellers uh that I think this is really going to disadvantage are the ones that need to sell in a hurry and have a have a change in in lifestyle.

um you know, for whatever reason. It generally it's never good. You know, if you have to sell a product uh uh product, if you have to sell a property in a hurry, there is a reason for that. It's never, you know, it's it's not necessarily ever advised by anyone. Um if you have to sell a property in a hurry, there's there's a reason for it. There's there's a change. And I don't know that you're ever going to pick up top dollar. And look if the New South Wales government would thought they they were bringing this in to benefit

Buyers, I I I think that's going to backfire in a major way because it's going

**Kasey McDonald** (17:42)

Yeah. Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (17:44)

to stop the ones who are genuinely motivated to move the property um from actually moving it. It won't stop them from selling it. Here's the crazy thing um that that you know very few people are talking about. The seller can still accept a lower price. It's not stopping that. It's stopping the advertising of the lower price. And the problem comes from

How do purchasers know and maybe maybe this is going to be part of it? We just have purchases coming in and lowballing everything because you might have, you know, a property in your street that's advertised at one point six that sat on the market for ages because they rejected an offer at one stage and they cannot market it any lower than that. Um, you're also gonna have I I think you're also gonna have um vendors, sellers, um, sacking their their real estate agents.

And just to sp to speak about this a little bit, when you are, let's say, one month into a campaign, in in a lot of the instances of the campaigns that I've done in the past, there has been a concerted reason as to why, you know, I would always look at a property and go, How am I going to market this product to market? Who's who's most likely to buy it? And then I would devise a strategy that would take time. Most good marketing strategies take time.

And let's say I'm a I'm an agent and I'm selling your house and I've told you we're gonna get one point seven for it. And you've agreed with that. I've shown you the comps. I've done everything that's there. You agree we're gonna go to market for one point seven. We put it at one point eight. We get an offer in at one point six five and you you and I both agree, like me advising

**Kasey McDonald** (19:25)

Uh-huh. Uh-huh.

**Peter Schravemade** (19:27)

you as you're a in a fiduciary interest, we both agree that we can probably hold out to one point seven. And then Jim Chalmers and Albo announced a tax thing, right? Like at

midway through the year. And, you know, all of a sudden that 1.7, no one saw it coming. We didn't know about it. They basically lied to us. We didn't know it was going to hit. And it could be that, it could be anything. I could get you could get sacked or whatever. I don't, I don't know. Uh or heaven forbid, something might change. And all of a sudden you are motivated to move that at 1.55, which is or 1.5, which you can sell it for, but you don't want to. You want to maximize the amount of money that you get for a property.

I I don't know anyone that doesn't want to do that. Like we all

**Kasey McDonald** (20:07)

Correct. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (20:08)

that's why we invest in property is to build build wealth through it. Anyone who doesn't do that, I mean, yes, it's shelter over our head and that's great and that's that's essential. But the secondary cause to that is we would like to, you know, use that property to accrue wealth. Um, so

**Kasey McDonald** (20:23)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (20:23)

we have something to lean on and we're not all on public money, you know,

**Kasey McDonald** (20:27)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (20:27)

in retirement. So I look, you know, I sit there and I look at this and I just go, you wouldn't be able to advertise that and you're most likely to sack me.

**Kasey McDonald** (20:35)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (20:36)

You

know, I and in there'd be inst interest there'd be instances where I I would actually advise you to do that. Um, but I you know, I don't know whether a secondary agent coming in can then advertise that below 1.6 if that's the number that you you looked at. Um well, it

**Kasey McDonald** (20:50)

Well that's not clear, right? Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (20:53)

doesn't seem it doesn't seem to be. I c I couldn't find any information to say that, you know, there's gonna be any leniency on that because I've announced five fifty what is it, a hundred and ten thousand dollar fines on this

**Kasey McDonald** (21:02)

Yes. Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (21:03)

and

And then crazy stuff like you have to pay for the valuer. Like you have to pay for the that there's not a valuer that agrees with sales prices. Um I I mean, uh I don't know if they know how this works, but the sales price never really agrees with where the value is at. It's always gonna sit ten percent under mostly. Um so that in itself, it just it just seems nuts. Like I don't,

**Kasey McDonald** (21:28)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (21:29)

I don't, I don't know.

**Kasey McDonald** (21:30)

But to your point just before, in regards to say from the buyer sense, you know, we're

**Peter Schravemade** (21:35)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (21:36)

we've all been learning that uh, you know, our ChatGPTs and Claudes and all of those, or you know, our AI is where the buyers are going to kind of say, Hey, this is what I'm looking

**Peter Schravemade** (21:46)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (21:46)

for in the market. This is the lifestyle, the location, the this is my price range. Now we all know that then when we've got those properties advertised through any of the portals that you do have, you know.

price guide kind of in the back, but then you've got what that that firm advertised price might be. So even AI is only going to pick those up based on what those advertised prices are. So if buyers are in the market going, yeah, that's suitable for me,

**Peter Schravemade** (22:10)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (22:11)

they can't actually even present. So it might that's where I'm understanding this, right? So that that

**Peter Schravemade** (22:16)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (22:16)

seller now can't accept an offer that if that buyer came in with at a hundred grand less and that could be an unconditional sale, could be cash and go, here you go.

Here is that 1.64, but I but now I can't give you the 1.65. I don't have it, but I've got 1.64. The seller has to go, sorry, we can't accept that.

**Peter Schravemade** (22:36)

Yeah, that's that's exactly where the way I read it. So

**Kasey McDonald** (22:39)

Yeah, yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (22:40)

I I I understand, I completely understand why the New South Wales agents are up in arms about this. uh it

**Kasey McDonald** (22:44)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (22:45)

it just seems like pure stupidity. And it does it still appears as though the minister, um, Anoulack, I think is his first name. I can't pronounce his last name, it's a long name. Um, but he he still appears as though he's not in discussions with the real estate institute of New South Wales. And I mean, that's where stupid legislation like this comes from when when

**Kasey McDonald** (23:05)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (23:06)

your operational body stops talking to your, you know, your regulatory body. I th I think they need

**Kasey McDonald** (23:12)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (23:12)

to work hand in hand even if they don't like each other. Um

**Kasey McDonald** (23:14)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (23:15)

it it's not a case of of um let's let's play personal politics. You and I don't like each other, so we're not talking. Like we you know, you would hope that there is some kind of professionalism where we we overlook that and we go, you know what? Um for the good of the property industry, I'm gonna go and have a con

conversation with the people who actually operate the industry to see what they might actually say about this law that we're bringing in. Um I I don't know. I don't know. It's

**Kasey McDonald** (23:40)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (23:42)

not the first time that you and I have looked at something and gone, where is the sense and where is the logic in that? Who is in charge?

**Kasey McDonald** (23:47)

So this, exactly. Do you think that we're gonna do you think that we're

gonna see the really smart New South Wales agents um stop taking early offers on email? Do you think that we will start to see a shift in negotiations done verbally again? And then when we're getting closer to where we need to be, that then it'll go to email? Do you think that's that's we'll start to see that? Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (24:05)

It'll go to voice. Yeah, it'll Yeah, it'll go to voice. I think it'll go to voice.

**Kasey McDonald** (24:12)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (24:12)

but but the but the the second part of that is like you've got to keep a register. I haven't spoken

**Kasey McDonald** (24:17)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (24:17)

about this. You've got to p keep an office register. What's

**Kasey McDonald** (24:19)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (24:20)

going to start happening is that people are not going to decline based on price, even if price is a factor. They're going to say it's another condition that didn't appeal to them. Um as

**Kasey McDonald** (24:28)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (24:29)

part of it. That's what I think is going to happen. And who does that disadvantage? Well

the purchaser, the person that this was actually put in there

**Kasey McDonald** (24:36)

Mm-hmm. Yep.

**Peter Schravemade** (24:38)

for, um, it will disiv it will disadvantage them greatly because they won't know. They'll be going to be shooting in the dark. You know, can you imagine if you're fifty thousand dollars under, but I can't tell you that because if I say if I say look I'm gonna I'm gonna di and I'm not I'm not f at a soliciting advice to New South Wales agents to not decline on price. That's not my job. But

I could certainly see this happening. I think people are going to decline based on conditions that's that are other than price. You know what I mean? Um, so they don't have to lock in that thing. Uh it yeah, just it's it's a mess. That is an absolute dog's breakfast if I've ever seen one.

**Kasey McDonald** (25:17)

Well, we're

gonna see it roll out next week and

**Peter Schravemade** (25:19)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (25:20)

um yeah, interesting times ahead for of course everyone in the real estate game out of uh New South Wales. So for anyone who of course would like to share, I guess, their

**Peter Schravemade** (25:31)

Uh

**Kasey McDonald** (25:31)

feedback and voice uh on that topic as it starts to play out and any experiences, you know, send us a holler at hello@beforetheweekend.com. We'd love

**Peter Schravemade** (25:39)

Yeah, we'd love to hear.

**Kasey McDonald** (25:40)

to hear. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (25:41)

Yep. Absolutely. Uh shall we move on to the next one?

**Kasey McDonald** (25:45)

Yes. You're calling BS.

**Peter Schravemade** (25:47)

I am. Yeah, I

uh it's not the first time. Look, I I saw an article this week. That's

**Kasey McDonald** (25:51)

No. Yeah yeah. That's a kind word for you.

**Peter Schravemade** (25:57)

right. I saw an article this week that is is bandying about a a claim that there's five hundred and nineteen prop techs fighting for agent attention. And I I just I like I just want to bring up the history of that number. Let me um

So I I think that number has come from it's it's a it's an association in Australia that's put that number forward. They say that at 519 businesses in the prop tech ecosystem cloud classified across 14 different categories. Um, and this is uh in in that this particular article that came out, they're talking about that um has been 39% growth from 2020 twenty-three. So two thousand twenty-three. Um

There isn't also uh a later post from the same association that says it maps at 571 organizations. So they're not prop techs, they're people who own organizations that might have multiple prop techs within it. Uh think of Cotality, for example, where you you you formerly worked at they have you know different products within there, but they're one organization. So

**Kasey McDonald** (27:06)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (27:07)

I I I take I take issue with these these numbers. So

If you look at the history of the prop tech maps and and I used to be vice president of one of these associations or the particular one that's talking about, in when the 2023 map came out, it identified 479 different prop tech products. And I I think that was pretty accurate at the time, that 2023 number. Um, there it was pretty easy to detect a prop tech back in those days. Um in 2023, generative AI had just come around. Um

And then you've got this 2026 number. So if you look at the disparity of uh 478 and all of a sudden we've grown to five hundred and nineteen, that would have to be an indust the slowest industry to adopt any kind of generative AI. If we've only gone from that number of 478 to 519 in the space of three years, we

**Kasey McDonald** (28:03)

Yeah, yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (28:03)

we have an inherent problem. But I I don't believe that that's the case. Um I think

That number of 519 is is deeply flawed. Um, we we at obviously I operate in that sector and we track over 600 of them. And we've just had an application period where we have, you know, obviously people apply for venture capital um and the accelerator program that sits as part of that. And I I think we have identified between 70 and 80 new forms of property technology that we weren't tracking as part of that 600. So, you know, for the first time ever, I'm actually saying that.

you know, anyone that's throwing around that 519 figure, um, that that could be from as far back as 2025. I think I would actually say there's about seven to eight hundred. And and I the why I throw the eight hundred in there is that I've just been overwhelmed um with this particular application program by

**Kasey McDonald** (28:59)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (28:59)

the sheer amount of single operators, owners, you know, that aren't trackable. And it's not

Not throwing shade at the people who use the the four five hundred and nineteen, but it's just um I I suppose exposing the gap between what is actually happening in the prop tech market now and where people think it is at, because we have, you know, um property managers in in their garage vibe coding at the moment and bringing forward what could have been considered a year ago to be a fairly mature prop tech.

Now, a lot of people are going to throw stones at that and go, it's vibe coded and whatever else. And the races for adoption, I agree with that. Um, vibe coding doesn't necessarily mean it doesn't work. there are lots of family offices in the in the area who are developing that themselves. Nearly every forward-thinking real estate office has some kind of vibe coding going on as part of it. a lot of the property technology companies that I see have have some kind of uh generative AI coding that's part of it as well. So

I just think it's time that we need to acknowledge the sheer volume of property technology that sits in the landscape out there and stop sort of hiding behind this this old fashioned number that sits there. Because I think I think on the front line, real estate um professionals are probably seeing just a huge barrage of of technology come coming through. And over in America it was no different. Um the the convention had less exhibitors.

But there were more people hanging around the convention that hadn't exhibited with their own product looking for ways to sort of get in there. And

**Kasey McDonald** (30:36)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (30:37)

so where I'm seeing these are all at incubation stage, which is right at the start, not necessarily accelerator phase. And um, that's what I think is wrong with this this um particular number is that, you know, it's only detecting the fairly mature companies. It won't detect half of those who exist that won't ever get to that stage. Or I actually think 70%.

of those those ones or even higher. It could even be as far as eighty percent of those incubation ones won't won't get to where it needs to be. What what are your thoughts? Like what are you seeing?

**Kasey McDonald** (31:10)

Yeah, um I well I'm definitely seeing to your point about, you know, a property manager in the garage doing some coding, um, that's actually what we're seeing. Um, and not just property

**Peter Schravemade** (31:18)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (31:18)

managers, but we're seeing um, you know, many of the businesses now going, well, okay, we've got sale like we've got twelve, we've got twelve tabs

**Peter Schravemade** (31:23)

Yep.

**Kasey McDonald** (31:25)

open, right? We've got this tool, this tool, this tool, this tool, this tool. And then some do this part of an integration, some do that part of an integration, but they know that they might need all 12 tools to achieve the the job.

But not all

**Peter Schravemade** (31:38)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (31:38)

12 actually effectively can speak to each other, but in the, I guess, those points that that you want it to speak to each other, right? Like because you don't want it to maybe do everything, but you need it to do this, to do that, to do that, right? Um, to get to that end result. And so I think that's where we're seeing um some evolution happening here from our property managers and salespeople and business owners in real estate.

**Peter Schravemade** (32:01)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (32:02)

Is that they're doing that coding to say, how do I get that information out of there and that out of there? And how do you make it all talk together so that it delivers me this? Um, because

**Peter Schravemade** (32:10)

Yep. Yeah. I d it's that's ex

**Kasey McDonald** (32:12)

we're missing those connections. I appreciate that

**Peter Schravemade** (32:15)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (32:15)

we have a CRM that might talk to this, but then it doesn't talk to that. So then everyone's going manually into programs, which it just becomes that lack of inefficient efficiency piece, right? But that's the thing I think is

**Peter Schravemade** (32:26)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (32:26)

happening. Um, is people are sitting there coding, saying,

Help me get all of these things to talk together and d to deliver me this data or these insights so that I can do this form of action. Um, that's absolutely what I'm seeing happening in Four Walls at the moment.

**Peter Schravemade** (32:42)

Yeah, exactly. And and a lot of it comes down to how do you find a prop t a prop tech. Well, I I I would say it's it it's it's a technology that has some kind of impact on the property market. And I

**Kasey McDonald** (32:52)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (32:53)

mean, I I know that, you know, the the the peak body that is out there, they they have 14 c categories. Like even looking within in those categories, there are so many just creeping up. And

**Kasey McDonald** (33:03)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:04)

to your point, one of them does just a small cog in what a larger uh you know, in what a larger brand name may do.

But that's still a prop tech. And um, I actually think it's it's now impossible to gauge the amount of of property technology uh companies that are out there. And and so we're gonna have to start moving to a model, I think, where we say income generating might be the way the way that we

**Kasey McDonald** (33:27)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:28)

the way that we move forward. But I mean there's there's a hundred ways around that. Like my best

**Kasey McDonald** (33:31)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:32)

friend's sister's girlfriend's dog's uncle's father now pays two dollars for that subscription per month because he loves me. Is that is that like is that income generating? Well

By the letter of the law, it is, you know, maybe it's adoption. Maybe you need to have more than 10

**Kasey McDonald** (33:46)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:47)

clients. But what's a client? If one of your clients is a massive juggernaut with 155,000 agents, you know, is that so there's a r I what I'm flagging more than anything at the moment is it is now impossible to sit there and say there are X amount of prop techs in the market and this is what they're doing. Um, I think that that side of it's becoming particularly difficult. And on the flip side to that, very, very difficult.

If you're a prof property professional, to sift between which ones are quality and

**Kasey McDonald** (34:16)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (34:16)

which ones aren't. Um, and it is so, you know, I looking at that space, that's one that I delve in a lot. But um I I'm getting tired of seeing that number bandaged around because I think I think it's like five years old now. Um, let's move on. and I'll get off my soapbox. Uh there's

**Kasey McDonald** (34:31)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (34:34)

another interesting one. And this one, you know, full disclosure, Properti is obviously a a um a property with an I, P-R-O-

P-E-R-T-I. It is obviously a company that REACH Australia has invested in. That's the company I represent. But this was an article not released by ours um this week. Uh CEO Craig Deveson audited 38,000 real uh Australian real estate agents. That's a fair number. I don't know how many we have in total at the moment, but that is that is a fair whack. And he found that the average agent scores just 46 out of 100 for digital visibility.

With only about twenty to twenty-five percent getting it right. And that kind of means that seventy-five percent of agents don't show up when vendors ask ChatGPT, perplexity, Google

**Kasey McDonald** (35:18)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (35:19)

AI, you know, Claude, whatever it whatever it is. What what do you what do you think of this? Like we, you know, we've been at conferences where we talk a lot about digital identity. What's your thoughts?

**Kasey McDonald** (35:27)

Mm-hmm.

Yeah. Well, I think actually Craig nailed it in the article by saying, and we touched on it last week actually around the realestate.com.au

**Peter Schravemade** (35:37)

We did

**Kasey McDonald** (35:38)

portal and the the fact that they don't allow the AIs to obviously scrape their tool, right? So, you

**Peter Schravemade** (35:44)

Yes.

**Kasey McDonald** (35:44)

know, they're they're certainly very big on having your profile on there and you make sure that you've got um everything updated. And I think that's unfortunately where both property managers I'll I'll

I'll talk to sales agents first. So sales agents are getting it wrong because they're just focusing their energy and investment there instead of,

**Peter Schravemade** (36:02)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (36:03)

you know, why is it that they don't have their own independent Kasey McDonald page that's promoting themselves? They're drawing everything back to that. Um, how are they, what's their Google footprint look like? And so by having it, I guess, more open and and understanding how they can draw people back.

To their brand, their own brand as a sales agent, but more importantly, the actual business name as well, instead of drawing everyone back to realestate.com.au, I think is the key here. And that's where the sales agents are getting it wrong, where property managers get it wrong is that we don't even put a profile up. Okay, working

**Peter Schravemade** (36:39)

Yeah. Yeah, well.

**Kasey McDonald** (36:41)

in that space, um, and my as a part of my day-to-day role is I am talking to property managers all day, every day about their pain points in their business.

And the solutions we've got that are able to help them, right? Now I can tell you right now that half of them don't have photos even on their own websites. There's no mobile number. There's

**Peter Schravemade** (37:01)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (37:02)

an info email. When you call reception, you say sorry, they're not available. Um, so property managers, we're getting it wrong because we just are are not profiling ourselves at all.

**Peter Schravemade** (37:14)

G

I I have actually been to property management conferences where people have recommended that the property managers don't appear publicly for security risks. You know, what what are you what are your thoughts?

you you're disagreeing with the one.

**Kasey McDonald** (37:29)

I'm staying silent

because I like I absolutely fully get it that we need to have security top of mind. Property managers

**Peter Schravemade** (37:37)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (37:38)

are entering people's homes, you know, sales agents are entering people's homes. But I respect the fact that there has to be a security level. And I think unless there was um you know DV cases or cases that required you to have your identity undisclosed, I fully respect that.

But we are also property professionals, but we're still not looked upon that in that light because we've got a blank, you know, mirrored face. we've got this white picture with this shadow sitting on a website. And so therefore then we're not forming relationships. And I think that's actually where a lot of the problem is, um, is

**Peter Schravemade** (38:16)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (38:16)

that someone says, well, you know, I want to search. I am trying to find the best sales agent in my area. What are they doing now to find that?

They're not going

**Peter Schravemade** (38:25)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (38:25)

to rate my agent anymore. And are they going to

**Peter Schravemade** (38:27)

Yeah and

**Kasey McDonald** (38:28)

realestate.com.au to find the sales agent? Because that's only just going to show you statistics, but is it truly going to tell you how that agent actually operates and their values, ethics, et cetera? Um, I think that's where everyone's

**Peter Schravemade** (38:41)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (38:41)

searching, right? To find different information through the AI platforms. So then how do we find the best property manager for our business?

**Peter Schravemade** (38:49)

Yeah, you did right. And we've spoken about this a lot. I think a lot of the tasks that have been pulled out of the property management role in the area of AI should actually lend the property manager back

**Kasey McDonald** (38:59)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (38:59)

to the area of developing connection and the relationship

**Kasey McDonald** (39:02)

Correct.

**Peter Schravemade** (39:02)

more, which would lead, you know, probably to having a a profile being a big thing. In i I I think I suppose the area, just to take this back to sales, the area that I'm a little bit i in disbelief is the is the amount of sales agents that have discarded this or or

don't see it as important. Um that that to me stuns stuns me. Um and would give, you know, a lot of the uh regional areas that I look at, it gives

**Kasey McDonald** (39:29)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (39:30)

um a major advantage to certain players who have jumped on it and are harvesting it very well. But interesting article. I think I think there's a lot more to be said on that. And I think there's a lot more to be done

**Kasey McDonald** (39:41)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (39:41)

sort of moving forward. Shall we go to our next story?

**Kasey McDonald** (39:44)

Yeah, definitely. What why top billers don't want their name on the door anymore? So let's talk through this.

**Peter Schravemade** (39:50)

Yeah, well well this this is again from an article this week, but we've we've been discussing this

**Kasey McDonald** (39:55)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (39:55)

a fair bit. It it's been industry news that um let's call it water water cooler discussion. I I have

**Kasey McDonald** (40:01)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (40:02)

a strong theory that the industry has moved from being a I wanna you know how it used to be when and and I was I was guilty of this. I I was a sales agent, um I I became successful in doing that and I wanted my own office.

And it almost seemed like that was the progression. You know, back when there was a day that you, you know, you sort of got a girlfriend, you got married, you have children, that was the industry expect expectation. I think just like that in the area of sales, you know, it you could probably add some various layers onto that. Like you become a salesperson, you add a partner to your team, maybe you become a team, then you become an office, and then you become hopefully

**Kasey McDonald** (40:41)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (40:42)

two offices, office with the property management department, then a

Then maybe two offices. That used to be the industry evolution of this is what you did as an agent. I think I think that's gone by the wayside.

People don't want to be a licensee in charge on on a building anymore. Ten years ago every every agent wanted to do that. I think today, um, between the a hundred and ten thousand dollar underquoting fines, I'll track enforcement letters, ATO office uh, you know, audit blitzes, New South Wales changes or let's go changes to regulation that are in there. Um, I think being a licensee in charge is a legal target. And I don't think many people want it anymore. And

As a result of that, I believe you're seeing condo consolidation. People are shutting up offices and they're

**Kasey McDonald** (41:23)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (41:23)

they're just joining as a salesperson to a to a significant other. What do you thought what are your thoughts?

**Kasey McDonald** (41:29)

Yeah, well, I think David's kind of sharing here that uh he believes giving top agents equity partnership in kind of side of that hub, right? Like is what he's sort of saying. Um, so you know, then you're sort of having that centralized uh, I guess, functionality. And we absolutely see that with so many models um across particular different tasks, right? I think the same week, if it wasn't this week, it was last week where YPA launched their agent to owner.

Mentoring pathway, um, which is obviously also a good it's something to have because, you know, like you said, traditionally you just you're a salesperson, then you kind of build a team, and then all of a sudden you're owning an office. But who's actually really taught you the pathway to actually get to that licensee in charge position? But I do agree, uh I'm seeing every day mergers and acquisitions um all of the time um coming through.

**Peter Schravemade** (42:25)

Yeah. And I'm

I'm

**Kasey McDonald** (42:26)

Just because

of the extra business pressures, I think, you know, as the licensee as well, you know, there is now so much more than ever before that you need to be responsible for. Um, and I think people are just looking and reviewing that and sort of saying, well, you know what? Maybe I don't enjoy this anymore. I don't enjoy being the licensee because, you know, all I'm doing is putting out buys, helping everyone with their problems. And then I've got to take on all this risk and liability. You know what? I just want to get back to selling.

**Peter Schravemade** (42:56)

Hmm. Yeah. And I I th I think we saw a lot of this in the buyers agent sector, um, where borderless buyers agents were jumping up, you know, and they were representing in it in in state areas, because you you kind of go where the investors want to be or you're selling

**Kasey McDonald** (43:12)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (43:12)

where the investors wanna be. And so I I think that party has well and truly popped at the moment and we're seeing either consolidation or or

You know, we I think we've seen a lot of people leave that industry and sort of move. But I definitely um I like the the point that he's making about, you know, instead of instead of just ha having the same model, why don't you give them equity? I I I suppose if I have to be the devil's advocate in this scenario, the only thing I'd throw back is that, you know, the average life cycle of some salespersons is between three and seven years. uh it's you know, depending on how they're set up and how they're

put in there, do you really want somebody who's going to be hanging around for that period of time having equity in your business? Or do you make that, you know, p potentially you make that um equity contingent on their involvement or something like that. I just don't know how you pay them out at the end if they've been successful and want to go to somewhere else. You know, the mess seems to be more about what happens if they're no longer there or they want to go to a rival, like what

what happens with that. I I I

**Kasey McDonald** (44:16)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:16)

think that's a greater discussion. Every time I get into this conversation with principals, that is their gen genuine fear is

**Kasey McDonald** (44:22)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:23)

like, what do how do how do we structure this? And maybe it's a shareholding thing, um,

**Kasey McDonald** (44:26)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:27)

you know, that's never un uh realized where it's not necessarily equity that you can pull out. You're just holding shares in that company. And then even if you do leave, you're kind of still rooting for that same company. I know that's the wrong word in Australia, but I've just come from America. Um you you're kind of still going for that um that

brand to move forward because you've got share shares in it. So I'm sure there are plenty of legal eagles that can figure out their way around that conundrum, but it's an inter it's an interesting one. Should we

**Kasey McDonald** (44:50)

Mm-hmm. Yeah, definitely. Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:55)

should we move on to the property management desk, which I think is squarely your table.

**Kasey McDonald** (44:59)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (45:01)

We got a story here that says 20 steps to fix one leaking tap. Look, I mean I read this story and I think I think this is a a bit of um I think there's a bit of uh

I don't think it takes 20 uh steps to fick a fix a property management tap. Certainly if you're using industry best software that does exist out there. And I think actually Australia is is cutting edge in that area,

**Kasey McDonald** (45:24)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (45:24)

Australia and New Zealand. In fact, so I'm not sure I agree with this, but let's let's go to the actual point because

**Kasey McDonald** (45:32)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (45:33)

you and I, Berth, both were at a property management conference, the first national one, a couple of weeks ago.

**Kasey McDonald** (45:37)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (45:38)

And um Hermione ran a great series on you know what what issues do we need to solve.

And maintenance was by far and away the issue. Um,

**Kasey McDonald** (45:46)

Absolutely. Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (45:47)

seemed to be the majority where the majority of people spent. So um what what are you what are your thoughts on on this maintenance direction that that's coming up, the the the true maths of property management burnout?

**Kasey McDonald** (46:01)

Yeah, look, I think that maintenance definitely is a pain point, but I think that it can be absolutely easily resolved, but it just comes down to the way in which you manage it from the outset. So it's about what you know how you set those expectations. And I think let's just remove the entire software conversation to one side for a minute, because yes, there are tools that absolutely are helping um improve this. And the way that

Tenants and owners are viewing and recording, et cetera, what the maintenance is. But I think it's a it's absolutely setting the scene from the beginning. Um, that's expectations with the landlord and the tenant um around what actually is a repair, what is maintenance, what's an improvement, what's a recommendation? Like I mean, actually sharing with them what are the differences. You know, what's compliance that you just and a minimum housing standard that is absolutely a non-negotiable? What does emergency mean?

And what are

**Peter Schravemade** (46:57)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (46:58)

those rules behind that? Right. So I think we don't spend enough time, and this is taking it my back to my point before about our ghost images on websites, is that we are not building relationships enough in this industry of property managers and we're not having those types of conversations. So it is why the owners, when the tenants report it, they say, I've got a leaking kitchen tap, and that's all they give you, because you never explain to them what you expect. You then write back and say, Can I have a photo of it? Well, I'm okay.

On a photo of a leaking tap, really. Um, then the owner says, Can I have a quote? Really? Do we need a quote?

**Peter Schravemade** (47:32)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (47:32)

Like, so it's all of these things. If we draw it back to the fact that they don't trust you, you haven't built a relationship, and that's why they're asking for all of these different things. Um, and then they just don't return your email. So if you probably break down all the steps, there could be 20 steps all involved, but

**Peter Schravemade** (47:46)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (47:47)

I think it starts way back at the beginning. And then add the tech layer in that we've now all got available. Because I never had that. I

**Peter Schravemade** (47:53)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (47:54)

never had.

The fantastic

**Peter Schravemade** (47:55)

Nah.

**Kasey McDonald** (47:55)

technology em available to me. But that's it's it's how you set the scene at the beginning. It is so important.

**Peter Schravemade** (48:02)

Yeah, I

I also, you know, what stunned me about property management when when I was involved in it, um, and we're going, you know, to for the listeners, we're going back to probably um when did I leave that job? Probably two thousand and eight. So um we're just shy, you know, that's eighteen years ago now. We're just shy of nineteen years away from that. So the industry has changed. I'm I'm more than happy to admit that. But what has stunned me about the tenants today is the the

I actually think they know less about maintenance than the tenants back in those days. I think there are things

**Kasey McDonald** (48:36)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (48:36)

that are well and truly considered um to be um the property manager's issue that in the day certainly wouldn't have been. We would never have thought that. Um and so it so that, you know, I don't know if we've been proactive about educating them in that area either. It it really stunned me when I sto I I I actually stepped into a property management business recently and saw

some of the things that people were asking for. Like some of them are uh as simple as changing a light bulb. Now

**Kasey McDonald** (49:04)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (49:05)

I would have been embarrassed to ask for somebody to change a light bulb back

**Kasey McDonald** (49:08)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (49:08)

in the day. Now I'm I'm well aware that some properties have really complex light bulbs that do require that. But uh I myself have had a a a a request from a tenant for an electrician to come out and change a light bulb. And by the by the time you start doing that it it bec it becomes very difficult. And I I I think also

the the legislation about muddying the waters about what is minimum standards and what isn't. You know, like um in one instance, you you leave a window open um in a wet season in Queensland, you're going to have mould on your curtain. Um is that is that your fault because you left the window open or is that the the the fault of the the landlord? You know, the these the minimum that would never have been a case that would come have come up, I think, in the past.

**Kasey McDonald** (49:56)

Correct.

**Peter Schravemade** (49:56)

But

But we're we're seeing all of those now. And

**Kasey McDonald** (49:59)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (49:59)

um I I definitely um, you know, don't necessarily uh envy the property manager's job. And uh I don't also don't think it's their job to sit there and educate, but it might be a simple case of coming up with resources about what, you know, here are examples of what you probably should suggest and

**Kasey McDonald** (50:16)

Correct. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (50:17)

here is what you shouldn't. Um they're pretty easy to do these days, even based on um, you know, the RTA has help guides. I know a lot of property managers are.

Are rolling their eyes at me at the moment, going the I'm not going to use them.

**Kasey McDonald** (50:28)

Yeah, yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (50:29)

But um, but that you might use that as a basis, you know, for what they're

**Kasey McDonald** (50:32)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (50:33)

actually putting out there. And and uh anyway, that it's a it's an interesting one. maintenance continues to be a a nightmare. And speaking of that, there's a blind a blind core deadline now. Explain explain this to yeah, explain this to me. I think I know what this is. Um I'm surprised it

**Kasey McDonald** (50:46)

Mm-hmm, eighteen days away, yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (50:51)

it is in in Queensland, is it not? Well.

**Kasey McDonald** (50:53)

Uh there is a blind

cord uh law in Queensland, yeah. Spot yeah, I haven't done it for a little while, but it's got to be labeled. yeah,

**Peter Schravemade** (50:56)

Well, I don't wanna put I don't wanna put you on the spot, but I th I thought there was yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (51:03)

it's got to have the compliance sticker on it. Just before we get to that though, I just want to add one tip for our listeners. Sorry, just on that other point,

**Peter Schravemade** (51:06)

yeah, sorry. Yeah. Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (51:09)

is that maintenance doesn't actually need to be a pain point. Um, but what I would encourage you to do is now use the AI functions um that you've got to actually.

draw out some statistics for you. How many work orders are you getting in? What's um, you know, what's the times of the day they're coming in? What are they reporting on? How long have they are they sitting there open for? Like actually, and I know some of the tools do it, but if you're not using tools that allow you to do it, get your AI to do this and surface every week in your property management meetings these kinds of data and this is what you should be talking about. And now how do we resolve them?

What are the solutions that we've got? And what do we need to fix? Do we then need to get AI to write us some case studies and tips and tricks that is in every single rental property about what's an emergency repair? You need to change the light bulbs, all those little tips that are going to help tenants. And that's where you draw them to. Do videos. Everyone's love for

**Peter Schravemade** (52:02)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (52:03)

video. Get on TikTok and do it, right? So my tips are think now how you can use AI to help you actually make sure maintenance is not a problem. Okay, I'll get on to the next piece around the line cord. Sorry, I just wanted to add that in. Like

**Peter Schravemade** (52:15)

You know, that's okay.

**Kasey McDonald** (52:15)

That's how people should

be using AI for, right? Like leverage how they can they can make it better, right? For themselves. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (52:18)

Well, I I reckon that I think that's a great it's a great example. Absolutely.

**Kasey McDonald** (52:24)

Yeah. So blind core deadline for Victorians, uh, one December. So only 18 days away. Um, so what's gonna happen? Uh, actually on so from that first, second of December, a landlord uh ignores the three emails to approve the $150 handyman. Um

To and now technically the property will be classified as illegal to re-rent under Victoria's Prove It Before You Advertise It Rules. So um that, you know, I'm not too sure exactly what is covered in terms of that plant blind cord legislation, but I

**Peter Schravemade** (53:00)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (53:01)

believe that it's got to have uh an anchor. So it's got to be um attached, so it can't be, you know, dangling, flying around. It's got to have that little kind of.

Plastic anchor that's kind of screwed to the window sill as an example, um, so that it's not uh enabled for a child to obviously get caught within those cords and it have a compliant label. Now we've had that in Queensland for a little while. Um, and

**Peter Schravemade** (53:28)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (53:29)

it's kind of been as a part of that legislation. But I guess the difference for Victoria is now if that's not done, uh, you will not be able to relay that property.

**Peter Schravemade** (53:40)

Yeah, and I've obviously you know I I have no problem with legislation like this because it's actually saving lives and the lives of lives of children. So, but this is more just a heads up. You it's 18

**Kasey McDonald** (53:46)

Correct. Mm-hmm. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (53:51)

days away. So get your act together. If you're not aware of that or if you have properties in that sector, look up your legislation, yeah, get them done.

**Kasey McDonald** (53:54)

Yeah. Get them done. Hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (53:58)

Um there's a private act leasing software trap. So after the first

**Kasey McDonald** (54:02)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (54:03)

of December comes the 10th of December Federal Privacy Act deadline. Now we've we've spoken about this before, but

**Kasey McDonald** (54:08)

Yeah, we did last week, yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (54:09)

Yeah, I think the thing is where agencies are turning over three mil more. Um, they face twenty two thousand dollar fines if they haven't disclosed an automated ranking scoring resul rules in

**Kasey McDonald** (54:19)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (54:19)

their leasing software or Excel sheets.

**Kasey McDonald** (54:21)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (54:22)

What what are they talking about here?

**Kasey McDonald** (54:24)

Yeah, so that's what we spoke last week around the automated computer that is actually

**Peter Schravemade** (54:30)

Ah

**Kasey McDonald** (54:31)

doing that analytics or that assessment. So within the application

**Peter Schravemade** (54:34)

Uh, right.

**Kasey McDonald** (54:36)

softwares, there's tools now that allows, I guess, to kind of go, this tenant is a five-star, this tenant's a three-star, right? As an example. Um, and what it's saying is that within now your privacy uh disclosures, you have to.

Have wording to the effect of how in which your computer generated analysis um is working so that it's it's disclosed to everyone. Um yeah, that's that's where now that's changing. Um there's

**Peter Schravemade** (55:05)

Yeah, yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (55:06)

some great articles actually out from Regate Legal, if anyone has heard of those. They were formerly ONO Legal, um, co-founder Kristen Porter.

**Peter Schravemade** (55:16)

yeah. Christian. Yep.

**Kasey McDonald** (55:17)

yeah. So um jump on, have a read. Fantastic article.

she also obviously clearly understands the real estate landscape and so the way in which her, and I think it's Luke uh who is also the business owner there, the way in which they drew write the article, believe me, it's in layman's terms, it's not illegal to speak. so we'll all understand exactly what it is that we need to do and be mindful of uh t before the tenth of December. So get on and have a read. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (55:42)

Yep, yep. Great.

Um, this next uh one that's on your desk, which uh, you know, we've spoken about before off air. What

**Kasey McDonald** (55:50)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (55:50)

what are your thoughts on this? So sales principles, panic buying rent roles. Um, and it's a it's two stories here. More doors, more problems is triggering walkout. So it's kind of a a conflicting story. In one side, we've got definitely what has been described as a rent roll frenzy. I mean,

**Kasey McDonald** (56:07)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (56:07)

that sounds as as as sensational as the weather these days. A rain bomb is about to hit you or you know, but um there is

**Kasey McDonald** (56:15)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (56:15)

definitely a rush to buy rent rolls. And then I also know that blindly chasing growth is definitely hurting PMs. are they two two factual stories? Is that are we calling an account on balance at the moment?

**Kasey McDonald** (56:28)

Yeah, um, I I would agree. I don't think it's happening everywhere, uh, but in it it certainly is happening where we are seeing some panic buying. Uh, we

**Peter Schravemade** (56:38)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (56:39)

are certainly also seeing uh a lot more rent rolls for sale coming to market uh as well. But you know, I think the the key here is that principals are trying to obviously recover the loss of the sales income, right? That they're not

**Peter Schravemade** (56:52)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (56:53)

having. So they're going and buying those rent rolls.

And they might kind of be within that, you know, under 500 to kind of top it up. But as a part of that process, they are just thinking, we'll just now share the load and we're going to add an extra 50 properties onto each of our portfolio managers here, but without truly understanding what else behind the scenes might need to be fixed. And I think that's probably

**Peter Schravemade** (57:14)

of course.

**Kasey McDonald** (57:15)

the key here. They're not saying, well, do we have any operational inefficiencies? Do we have the right tools? What is it that we need to do to make sure we're retaining our people?

and that we've got the best processes in place here before we actually made this decision. Uh, so you know, not just bringing new properties into your already existing ecosystem doesn't mean it's also going to be an easy acquisition. Uh, I've

**Peter Schravemade** (57:38)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (57:38)

helped and supported businesses in the past. It's about planning for that, but also making sure you do your right due diligence in the one you're buying, because coming, you know, remembering that you've got.

Those properties coming into an ecosystem in the way that you've managed what your operational processes are. And again, it comes back to that educational piece we were just talking about. You've then got landlords that say, Well, I'm not used to having that style of communication and I want it done like this. And then you end up actually losing them um as a part of

**Peter Schravemade** (58:08)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (58:08)

the process. So uh not saying don't do it, because I think we probably do need to assess during these slower market times, now is the time to invest in our most important asset.

I do agree with that, but invest in it in your four walls first and then consider

**Peter Schravemade** (58:24)

Yeah. Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (58:25)

what you need to do to acquire.

**Peter Schravemade** (58:27)

Yeah, we've definitely seen you you and I have definitely seen quite a few um uh rent rolls for sale, right? Like the there

**Kasey McDonald** (58:32)

Mm. Absolutely.

**Peter Schravemade** (58:33)

it seems it seems as though it it is at there's quite a lot of that happening um at the moment. So that

**Kasey McDonald** (58:38)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (58:39)

those those two stories and I I've seen a lot of churn in pro the property management space. So I I think a lot of those is actually um coming true at the moment. Um this next story

**Kasey McDonald** (58:47)

Mm-hmm. Yeah. Very tired.

**Peter Schravemade** (58:49)

This next story is from the investor property area. Um do you do you want me to run you through it or are you I mean I

**Kasey McDonald** (58:56)

Yeah, I

actually haven't seen this one. So um if you wouldn't mind.

**Peter Schravemade** (58:59)

Yeah. Well what so yeah,

what normally normally h normally happens, I shouldn't say normally, the buyer's agent industry had a lot of we just said on on air before a lot of um, you know, sort of flyby nighters or people who would act in a geographical location because that's what was selling to the to the investors. So that that you know, that t technically sells stuff. And in the market that I grew up, I I'm gonna go back to, you know, the prehistoric era when I where I was a salesperson. Um

And people were rolling in. I was operating in a place called Rockhampton and Gracemere was a a uh place that people didn't want to live in. It's not anymore. You know, we're 20 years later, it's moved on. But generally the way a market evolves is that the investor investment property salespersons get in there first. And back in the day, there were some small operators and there were some companies that actually built their houses and whatever else. And we knew we were an operational agency in town. We were quite large at the time. We were very successful. Um people would

come in and that that that advertise properties for sale in Gracemere people who don't know the difference between Rocky and Gracemere. There's a good 30 minute drive out there. Now it used to be 15 back back then or 1520 as a minimum, a 20 minute drive to Gracemere. So it was some way away and it's separated by floodplain. There's no way

**Kasey McDonald** (1:00:15)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:00:16)

you're ever going to build between here and there. Most of Rocky used to flood. So you know that build out there and and it was more the inconvenience of living out of town. Like you know, back in the day there wasn't a

There wasn't a servo that was open past nine at night, for example. So if you ran out of milk, you had a 20 minute drive to get it. And the technically the properties should be cheaper and the ones that we were selling were. But what we were well aware of is investment property salespersons would come in there and they'd sell these properties at more more money than we were selling them at. Like um back in the day by a hundred thousand dollars more. And that was nearly a quarter of the property back then. And they were also quoting rental numbers that just didn't stack up in our area.

Right. So, you know, like if if the average property was renting for five hundred dollars a week, these guys would be saying six hundred and fifty dollars, so a hundred and fifty dollars extra in extreme circumstances. But even on the minimum, they were kind of saying five fifty, even though we would back

**Kasey McDonald** (1:01:10)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:01:11)

up five hundred. And what this next article talks about is um how there's a bit of a hangover from buyers' agents who've who've pulled out of certain markets and they're they're specifically naming ones out of Geelong, Logan.

Perth. They'd they've been in them selling them, promising huge rental yields. Um, and a lot of those buyers agents aren't even in the market anymore. They've sold to investment, they've sold to investors. Now investors have picked it up and then they're they're finding that they're going to local agents, and the local agents are saying you're just not going to get that for your rent. So they're

**Kasey McDonald** (1:01:44)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:01:44)

now advertising it at $50 to get to get a rent, um, you know, to get some kind of rent um in or tenant in place.

Um, and I mean some of it could be subject to market conditions, Kasey. Maybe the markets come back. I'm not throwing shade at those investing investment property specialists, but I have actually I've I I've actually experienced this firsthand. Um

**Kasey McDonald** (1:02:06)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:02:06)

and and look, you know, if I if if you're an investor out there and you listen to this podcast and you're looking at going into a market, don't ever accept the rental appraisal that's put in front of you by a property investment

**Kasey McDonald** (1:02:16)

Yeah, I agree.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:02:17)

salesperson.

I I would regularly um, you know, w before I invested, call up a local agent, send them a floor plan in some a s a local property manager, send them a floor plan and say, what do you think of this in this location? And and, you know, between there and what the investment property salesperson said, you you're probably gonna find the truth um in in what it is. And so that becomes your assumption. We're gonna rent it out for that at this particular stage. And you should also do maths around what if the market changes and all of these things and

So this that article is talking about a hangover of local buyers agents who were in town selling and they're now gone and the local PMs forced to pick up the um the slack of all of these investors that are sitting there and they're kind of saying you're not going to get that free rental. Does that does that make sense to you? Have you seen this before?

**Kasey McDonald** (1:03:05)

Yeah, absolutely.

Yeah. Look, it's definitely has been um something pretty common. Like even in the past, right? When I was in property management, you would tend to get that owner that would come to you um after the fact. And you you would unfortunately. Um, and and probably sometimes not just the investor stock. I actually do see it. And please, salespeople listening, don't hate me for this, but you also do do it. Um

You say, yeah, fantastic to that buyer if you're having this as an investment. And may and obviously maybe not now, but in the past you've definitely gone, yeah, yeah, you'll easily get seven hundred. Um and then the BDM or the property manager walks in and says, yeah, no, we're nowhere near that. Um, so it's kind of the same analogy, but yeah, definitely have seen it. Yeah. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:03:44)

Can I t can I tell you a story about that from the salesperson's perspective? I don't I don't think I've ever

aired this publicly before, but you know, it's it's been nearly 30 years. Um, in in my particular sales office, it was a well known fact that the we we weren't allowed to do that. We'd have to get the property manager to

**Kasey McDonald** (1:04:00)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:04:00)

sign off on it, um, which you would agree with, right? You'd give that a tick.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:04:03)

Great.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:04:04)

But our property manager was ultra conservative, and there was like one across the road who I knew personally. We'd grown up

**Kasey McDonald** (1:04:08)

Yeah. uh

**Peter Schravemade** (1:04:11)

in school together, and she was way better.

like I don't know.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:04:14)

uh

**Peter Schravemade** (1:04:16)

I'm not gonna say at at actually managing. I'm sure

**Kasey McDonald** (1:04:20)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:04:21)

I'm sure the one that we had was excellent, very, very experienced. But the one across the road could actually get you know to the extent of fifty and sixty dollars per week. And so I would get a rent appraisal from that person as well. I'd put the two of them together and guess who who they would go across to. So if if you're listening, if you're listening out there and

And you are in that scenario, be very aware that's that salespersons

**Kasey McDonald** (1:04:44)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:04:46)

also do, you know, at that time I did understand the the the the rental market and I just couldn't sell in a competitive market if we were constantly saying what was less than what the market would actually say out there. So I don't recommend that for any salespersons out there, but that that was certainly what was going on. Anyway, moving on from that, I hope

**Kasey McDonald** (1:05:05)

Yeah. Anyway, can I can I

just add some additional data in here? I know boring kind of data, but I just I saw this article from Reet, so real estate industry partners, for those that do know. I just want to quickly

**Peter Schravemade** (1:05:17)

yes.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:05:19)

run through it just before we get off of the property management uh desk today. I just felt it was a really good piece for everyone to understand um principles as well. Need to know this if you don't. Um, but more importantly, property managers, right? There definitely is.

Some pressure out there. Now, this data has come from them via for Victoria only for the month of November. And it is basically indicating one property, two households under pressure. Let me just explain it to you. So we've got the advertised median rent at 570. This is the example. The advertised medium rent at a lease renewal, 525. So days to lease, so advertised time, 19 days. Um, again, just a sample, but that this is the tenancy pressure.

Properties given a notice to vacate from the 12 months to October for all dwelling types. Rental arrears, 33.7%.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:06:12)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:06:13)

The owners selling 31%, and the owners moving in 16.3%. Okay. So there's one piece of data there that you all need to be aware of about what exactly is going on and understand within your own ecosystem. Now here's the investor pressure. The RBA obviously, you know, raised uh rates again.

so if the weekly example uh was on a $604,000 loan at an interest rate of 6.75%, principal and interest over 30 years, right? So standard staff, the rent that they would receive is $600. The interest only repayment on that loan is $784. The principal and interest is $904. They're getting $600 a week.

So they're already

**Peter Schravemade** (1:06:59)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:07:00)

at a loss if they're doing principal and interest at $304. That's not taking into account the management fees, the rates, their insurance, like all of the costs to actually have that investment property. Correct. So property

**Peter Schravemade** (1:07:10)

Yeah, just on the Yeah, just on the line itself. Hm.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:07:15)

managers, there is pressure there, and you might not be seeing it fully yet. Uh, but tenants have hit affordability ceilings and owners are struggling behind the scenes. And now more than ever.

This is the time that you need to build those relationships. And you need to dive deep into understanding this data and to be able to have the conversations about this is where your yield is at. This is what we need to do to improve the property to be able to achieve this. This is why I think we have to keep this tenant on instead of trying to re-advertise again. Or whatever those conversations look like, pick up the phone and have them. Know the data

**Peter Schravemade** (1:07:53)

Yeah. Yep.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:07:55)

in your space.

And learn about these types of things so you can help them and provide solutions and options. And that's what your role is. Be that advisor to say, here's a solution. Here's an option for you. Hey, chat to this person, they might be able to help you. It doesn't mean that you need to know the ins and outs of everything, but guide them in the best way so they can make the best decisions.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:08:17)

Yep, very good. And um yeah, I I would echo all of those sentiments. I think I think that's exactly where we sit at the moment. Um I I I think there are a lot of landlords still doing okay, especially the older ones, but um, you know, the ones I shouldn't say older, the ones that have been I'm trying to avoid their generational thing, but the ones that have been in market a bit longer and have yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:08:35)

Yeah. Hundred if they've owned their properties for uh

a lot a fairly, you know, I guess, what would we say more than ten years, do you think? Um, they're probably they're probably doing okay in that sense. Yeah. Correct.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:08:42)

Yeah. Yeah. Yep. But you can you can figure that out. Like you can see that.

You've got all of the data in the world to have a look at that. Or if you don't, you know, we've mentioned tools in the past like Zapiio that help you with that. Let us move on. So

**Kasey McDonald** (1:08:57)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:08:58)

um yeah I'm gonna run run over this quickly. Uh it's a

**Kasey McDonald** (1:09:01)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:09:02)

one one I picked up Accountants Daily ATO sentiment report revealed that nearly 30% of accountants

had real estate clients hit with ATO audit or debt recovery action in the first in the the past quarter, making real estate the the second most targeted industry in Australia. Um crucially seventy six percent

**Kasey McDonald** (1:09:19)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:09:20)

of the targeted real estate businesses turn over less than two million dollars a year.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:09:24)

Well.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:09:24)

So that's that's saying the the that's accountants saying that the small businesses are getting smashed by the ATO and it you know might be their fault. I'm not I'm not drawing any bows

**Kasey McDonald** (1:09:35)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:09:36)

there, but um

You know, I think one of the things that the ATO is targeting is if an agency earns over a hundred thousand dollars for 90 days and isn't on an active payment plan, the ATO now reports the default straight to credit bureaus. Um and in the same week, um, the top five AML/CTF agents cat mistakes catching agencies out um

**Kasey McDonald** (1:09:58)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:09:59)

was released uh the where where basically um we're looking at um these are the things that agencies aren't

aren't doing as far as AML/CTF. Now you're still

**Kasey McDonald** (1:10:09)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:10:10)

in a from what AUSTRAC said, and this is Brendan Thomas, the head of AUSTRAC said, you're still in a bit of a a leniency period. So it might just be a bit of a a time to get your head around the things that you aren't doing. Um

**Kasey McDonald** (1:10:24)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:10:24)

but but the big one is failing to verify the beneficial owners behind family trusts and company buyers. That is

**Kasey McDonald** (1:10:30)

Uh-huh.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:10:30)

particularly difficult. Um

Yeah. So I, you know, that's that's the big one that they're after. And I just thought I'd touch on that. We also have a Victorian rental provider fine $20,000 over

**Kasey McDonald** (1:10:42)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:10:42)

unlimited access lease clauses. I didn't know this was a thing. And maybe you can comment on this, but um

**Kasey McDonald** (1:10:49)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:10:50)

regulators, regulators have found that this housing provider had unlawful clauses written into the residential tenancy agreements, giving itself unlimited access to tenants' homes. Have you ever heard of this before?

**Kasey McDonald** (1:11:02)

Uh well, I've heard of people writing in c you know, um, incorrect clauses uh into tenancy agreements, but certainly not that one. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:11:11)

Unlimited access

to tenants' homes. I mean, I I haven't ever heard of that. I think I d

**Kasey McDonald** (1:11:14)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:11:15)

I don't think there's a a state in the nation that would ratify that. Not one that I know of.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:11:17)

No, that's correct. They're all very all

very, very strict in terms of entry and access. Like it it's something that you certainly, you know, cannot just I'm not gonna do that clause, but I'll write my own. Um, I've not

**Peter Schravemade** (1:11:29)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:11:30)

seen that for this case, yeah. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:11:32)

Yeah. And

there's there's a bit of a reminder there from um Stacey Holt,

**Kasey McDonald** (1:11:36)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:11:36)

who does a lot of compliance stuff in the Queensland area. Uh she's saying that when a tenant exits under uh DFV provision, so um that is a D V uh thing, isn't it? It's a domestic and family violence. Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:11:48)

Yes, yes, it is. Divine. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:11:50)

Yeah. the the PMs must be surgical at the outgoing inspection. So a victim survivor is never pursued for perpetrator damage. Very,

**Kasey McDonald** (1:11:58)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:11:59)

very difficult for the PM to get this right, but um

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:01)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:02)

very important as well. Like, you know, we don't want to per we don't want to survive a

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:05)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:06)

um, you know, smash just because of of paperwork. But yet

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:09)

Correct.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:10)

again, it falls to the poor property manager to arrange for that. So

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:13)

Yeah,

I just read that the clause that they wrote and sorry, it says the owner can inspect the garden shed whenever they like.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:21)

is that all? Well that's not too bad, right?

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:22)

That's what it was.

Yeah. But still.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:25)

Wow.

Wow. I mean well, but but there's

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:30)

Yeah. Twenty they got fined twenty thousand dollars for that.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:33)

there's a way around that though. Like I mean

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:35)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:36)

you don't write that into the exclusive use area. Anyway, I'm s I suppose

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:40)

Correct. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:41)

well that's yeah, that's interesting. That's um

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:43)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:43)

let's move on from both of those. Um yeah, yeah, you'd

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:46)

Yeah, what's this one? A new your deposit bounced?

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:49)

Yeah, this is happening. This

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:50)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:50)

happens a lot. So this one's over in WA after a home buyer lost nearly 200,000. I think it's only, what

**Kasey McDonald** (1:12:55)

Okay.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:12:56)

are we talking, a hundred and seventy dollars shy of that or seventy? No, a hundred and seventy dollars shy of that. Hackers intercepted their email. So this happens all the time. Um

**Kasey McDonald** (1:13:05)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:13:06)

this week, Kasey, I purchased a car. Um I

**Kasey McDonald** (1:13:09)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:13:09)

I and as part of that, I had to wire a small amount of money, it wasn't a large amount of money,

**Kasey McDonald** (1:13:14)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:13:15)

to

Uh a fairly well recognized car brand. I won't tell you which

**Kasey McDonald** (1:13:20)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:13:20)

one. And their account got flagged as being a non-conforming account by banks. So banks actually sit there now and go, There's never been any money put into this account. Do you think you should be putting it to there? And

**Kasey McDonald** (1:13:32)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:13:33)

you know, when I spoke to the the car company about that and suggested that they change their practices, I was met with um a great bit of disbelief. But back to this, back to

**Kasey McDonald** (1:13:42)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:13:43)

this story.

and you know, cause that that that's this is how common this type of practice is. This

**Kasey McDonald** (1:13:49)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:13:50)

this particular story is where they've intercepted somehow, they've intercepted the emails um with their mortgage broker and they've set set up a s a fake settlement account. So the mortgage broker sent through details. Generally they will have intercepted that and changed the account details on that. I've seen this dating back to you we have a very good mutual friend who I assisted with this particular thing.

back in 2013. So it's not new to the industry. It was going on back then. Um, but yeah, we it it happens all the time. I think

**Kasey McDonald** (1:14:22)

All the time.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:14:23)

you need an office policy. I don't care whether your sales, rentals, whatever the hell you are, if you are

**Kasey McDonald** (1:14:29)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:14:29)

transferring money over above a certain amount and you will need to make a decision as to what that is in your office, that could be one grand, you know, if your exposure, if

If you're living on paycheck to paycheck as a small office, that could be one grand. If you're a bigger office and you can take a bit of a hit and it's an operational problem, that might be five or ten grand. I don't know where that line is for you, but you need to have an inter-office policy that when you're transferring things above that amount, you must you must call and verify the account details to where that is going. There's just not

**Kasey McDonald** (1:15:00)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:15:01)

a a non-negotiable. So, you know, when

When somebody's transferring a hundred and ninety-nine thousand, I mean, I kind of throw this back to the mortgage broker involved

**Kasey McDonald** (1:15:09)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:15:10)

in the deal. I don't know the exact uh you but somebody in there has to say to them, you're transferring nearly two hundred thousand. Let's make sure this happens in a reasonable fashion. I don't know who it is, but they've stuffed that one up. Um

**Kasey McDonald** (1:15:22)

Definitely.

Happens all the time. I see it. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:15:24)

Y yes, Anthony Di Nardo, who, if you remember back a couple of episodes ago, is accused of sexually

**Kasey McDonald** (1:15:29)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:15:30)

assaulting eight former eight former female staff. accused, alleged. This is alleged. It's not proven. Um, the the court case has been moved from Newcastle to Sydney. Um, so you know, that's just to watch this space. They're they're actually saying, I think, that he has no chance of getting a um a a jury in that scenario that

doesn't know him or know the case. So they're going to move

**Kasey McDonald** (1:15:54)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:15:55)

it to Sydney where it may be um a you know a fairer process because we we still need he's still innocent until proven guilty. So we're that's a watch this space for that one. The um the other one that came through is ASIC have launched a formal investigation into the three point four billion dollar collapse of Western Sydney developer, the Bathla Group. Now we've covered this in the past, right? We spoke about

**Kasey McDonald** (1:16:17)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:16:18)

this Bathla Group. It was really that almost happened immediately after the the

the tax changes came through. I'm not saying that that was

**Kasey McDonald** (1:16:23)

Mm. You did. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:16:25)

part of it, but yeah, that it's ASIC need to investigate stuff like this. there are a lot of lot of tradies without money in there. And I don't know who's right or wrong, but certainly I'm hoping an investigation comes to the the tail end of it because we we've got to stop seeing this. Now um we are out of time, but let's go to our Friday feel good. And and I like this one.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:16:44)

Yes. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:16:47)

Um, so this is a story of a 19-year-old kid called Matthew Farrugia. He cold

**Kasey McDonald** (1:16:52)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:16:53)

called a mobile number one number on one of Tim Andrews' for sale signs asking for a state start in real estate, even

**Kasey McDonald** (1:16:59)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:17:00)

though no job was advertised. And uh, you know, here we are after 15 years. Um, they've been working side by side. He's just completed a five-year accession succession plan. I I love I love

**Kasey McDonald** (1:17:10)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:17:11)

this because there are not enough agencies, principles with a succession plan in place.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:17:16)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:17:17)

um you know what is going to happen once I depart or if something goes wrong. Um I've heard Michael Nitschke speak about this, the, the, the bloke um from Adelaide, where

**Kasey McDonald** (1:17:24)

Yes. Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:17:26)

his father, you know, became ill and there was no succession plan and he had to pick up the pieces. And fortunately he's on his feet. But I love the fact that um, you know, that this kid who's called the sign 15 years ago

**Kasey McDonald** (1:17:38)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:17:38)

is now is now full ownership of of LJ Hooker Terrigal. Um and

**Kasey McDonald** (1:17:44)

Yeah, well

done, Matthew.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:17:45)

Yeah, yeah, that's that's I don't I don't know the guy. Do you know who he is?

**Kasey McDonald** (1:17:49)

No, I like I've I've heard of Matthew before, um, but no, don't have not met him. So yeah, yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:17:52)

Hmm. Haven't met him either. No,

no. Um, and we've seen a couple of other ones change hands here, but I think that's the that's the good one to sort of um end the end the show with what do you reckon, Kasey? Like, do you have do

**Kasey McDonald** (1:18:04)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:18:05)

any any other any other feel good stories that you you wanna you wanna bring to the fore?

**Kasey McDonald** (1:18:11)

No, I think that's a really brilliant one to end on, actually. Um, you know, I I think it's it's super exciting. But you know what's actually um I think so positive about that is that uh as a 15-year-old, you had the guts to go, this is what I want to do, this is where I see myself. And I'm I'm just gonna absolutely give it a crack. I'm gonna call this person and I'm gonna see if they've got a job and what it is it's gonna take me to get there. Um, so I just

I that's what I absolutely love about this. It's probably like how it actually started and well done and obviously where it's ended. So um I think it a

**Peter Schravemade** (1:18:46)

Yeah. Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (1:18:47)

really great feel good Friday for us to end the show on today.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:18:50)

Yep. And and that is um that is our Friday, the th the thirteenth of November. Is that a spooky day? I know the number 13's

**Kasey McDonald** (1:18:55)

Mm-hmm. uh

**Peter Schravemade** (1:18:57)

weird. We discussed this before. We can't decide whether it's Black Friday today or not. So if you know the answer to that, shoot us a message. But it's wonderful to have you listening to us from

**Kasey McDonald** (1:19:04)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:19:05)

wherever you're listening to us. Um I ran into a few people during the week that I did not expect were listening to us from over in America. So that was

**Kasey McDonald** (1:19:12)

Right.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:19:13)

a that was kind of weird. I don't know what they get out of this. They're just twist it if you're listening to this hello guys, like.

I'm sorry that you had to sit through an hour of us banging on about Australian real estate, but that's what it is. And wherever you are, whatever you're doing, whether you're putting open signs out, whether you're doing open for inspections, whether you've got the weekend off, half your luck. Um, it's great to have you with us, right, Kasey?

**Kasey McDonald** (1:19:34)

Yeah, absolutely. Uh enjoy your weekend, everyone. Hopefully everyone's out there uh getting the results that they're looking for for both their sellers and of course their landlords. but that's a wrap for us on before the weekend on Friday the thirteenth. Ciao.

**Peter Schravemade** (1:19:49)

Ciao.