A Lifetime Ban, the Excel Spreadsheet Rule and an Auction Blitz

Episode 26 · Fri, 6 Nov 2026 · 52m

This week on Before the Weekend, Kasey McDonald and Peter Schravemade work through a heavy week - a market softening on every front, renters at their ceiling and the courts finally catching up with some of the industry's worst operators. First, the numbers. The Melbourne Cup Day rate hike takes the cash rate to 4.85 per cent, capital city days on market have stretched to 39 - the longest since August 2020 - and median vendor discounting has hit 4.7 per cent. Westpac is forecasting a further 11 per cent fall in national house prices, while REA reports distressed listings up 42 per cent year on year. Then the rental market. Vacancy has hit a five-year high of 2.4 per cent, annual rental growth has slowed to 5.2 per cent and advertised rental listings are up 8 per cent year on year. Kasey takes it back to Tim Lawless of Cotality, who told the show in May that renters were already at their affordability ceiling. Perth is cooling fastest, while Queensland stays tight with average tenancies stretching to 21 months. Then the privacy deadline property managers can't ignore. From 10 December, new Privacy Act rules on automated decision-making cover any pre-programmed, rule-based program that scores rental applicants - and the explanatory memorandum names an Excel spreadsheet. Peter's verdict: "That's a sledge at the property management industry if I've ever seen one." Then the portal wars reach court. A judge has ordered REA Group to substantiate its "nine in ten buyers" claim in Domain's lawsuit, and Peter makes the argument nobody else is making - REA blocks AI from scraping its site, so buyers searching with AI are finding homes somewhere else. Then the Bank of Mum and Dad. With capital city values down 8.1 per cent since March, parent guarantors face a $50,000 exposure, upgraders on bridging finance are watching their homes sit for 39-plus days, and the last two hikes have taken 55 Victorian suburbs out of reach for the average borrower. Then the story of the week. QCAT has banned Venetia Story from real estate for life after finding she ran a trust account before her company held a corporate licence, drew a flat $6,000 a month from it and added GST on top of GST-inclusive commissions. A full Federal Court bench has since declared her a vexatious litigant after 24 proceedings in seven years, and she has been removed as executor of her father's estate. Also this week: Place launches a 200-home auction blitz after 3 in 4 Brisbane auctions failed, Phil Parker calls for random drug testing of agents, NSW Fair Trading puts PMs on its 2026-27 compliance target list, three agents are charged over the alleged kidnapping and robbery of a tradesman, Fair Work upholds the sacking of a CBA lending executive over a secret referral web, and the REIQ Awards honour Tenancy Skills Institute, McGrath North Lakes and Kollosche. Before the Weekend is a weekly podcast for Australian property professionals, hosted by Kasey McDonald and Peter Schravemade. New episodes every Friday.

Full transcript

**Peter Schravemade** (00:05)

Hello and welcome. it is episode 26. and the date today is 5th of November. Although it is the 6th of November if you're in Australia. I happen to be in the US at the moment, so just kicking back in Bourbon Street. Sounds like a bit of a humble brag, but no, I'm I'm actually

**Kasey McDonald** (00:19)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (00:20)

here on business. I've got the National Association of Realtors Annual Conference, which I come over here for annually. and that kicks off tomorrow. So I'm looking forward to that. I joined by um

The CEO of the REIQ is over here, Antonia, and I might be able to catch up with her tomorrow. See if we can

**Kasey McDonald** (00:37)

Right.

**Peter Schravemade** (00:37)

get some other interviews in. But in the interim, I have the effusive. Let's go with that as a as a a descriptive word. Kasey McDonald, she is joining me from Brisbane, all the way from Brisbane. How are you, Kasey? What's going on?

**Kasey McDonald** (00:50)

Hmm. Yeah.

Pretty good actually. Nice to have a bit of a down week of no travel. Sorry to rub that in. I'm sure that you're sleeping out of a suitcase, you know, in a hotel.

**Peter Schravemade** (00:58)

thank you. Thank you for that.

**Kasey McDonald** (01:01)

Yeah, just chilled, you know. yeah,

**Peter Schravemade** (01:03)

Right there.

**Kasey McDonald** (01:04)

well, no certainly not chilled, but just nice to kind of actually be at home and have a bit of a reset,

**Peter Schravemade** (01:08)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (01:09)

reset week. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (01:11)

Yeah, that would be nice. Unfortunately not happening for for me until the end of November, but hey, it is what it is. look,

**Kasey McDonald** (01:14)

Yeah. Let's see it.

**Peter Schravemade** (01:17)

we got some stories. We got some stories today. So the obviously there's been a a rate hike and I d I don't think we'll focus

**Kasey McDonald** (01:23)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (01:23)

on that. We ch generally tend not to, but interesting. Melbourne Cup Day rate rate hike. I don't know how often that happens. I probably the biggest talking point is that we're at a at a eighteen year high, right? It it it is ridiculous.

**Kasey McDonald** (01:34)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (01:35)

And then we've got ABC and Cotality home value index, so biggest downturn they're saying in in 40 years. we've got a discount and yield reality check. So capital city median days on market sitting at 39 days, which is the longest um since August

**Kasey McDonald** (01:51)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (01:52)

2020. And median vendor discounting hit hit four point seven, so that's the largest since the pandemic, May 2019, since before the pandemic.

And then modeled three month sales volumes are down twenty three percent. It's not good news. let's move on. Westpac's eleven eleven

**Kasey McDonald** (02:08)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (02:09)

percent drop call and forty two percent distressed listing surge. so you know, they're basically saying on on top of all of the bad news that we've just had, the rate hike and everything else, they're forecasting a further eleven percent national house price fall.

Meanwhile, the REA group are revealing that distressed property listings have jumped forty two percent year on year, which is just crazy. a big New South Wales auctioneer defection. So Ray White's excuse me. Ray White's chief auctioneer for New South Wales jump ship to Bresic Whitney. Well he's gonna be mentoring the batik network there. w a Granny flat builder collapse. So

**Kasey McDonald** (02:45)

Right.

**Peter Schravemade** (02:46)

um you know, we've been looking at

Granny flats quite a bit and what they can do, especially in rent rolls. And it's interesting that one's collapse here. We're gonna look a little bit at that. and purportedly one point four million dollars in losses there. But

**Kasey McDonald** (02:58)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (02:59)

let's go over to you. So you've got a few property management stories this week, right?

**Kasey McDonald** (03:05)

Yes. I think, I just wanted to probably draw into the rental market initially and kind of look at where those uh I guess vacancy rates and where things are really changing and and how maybe it's also starting to soften a little across the rental market or should I say maybe we've had a little bit of a rebalance. and and not in all states, based on the statistics. So

what I actually read through the Cotality and ABC actually uh did an article as well on this is that we've actually hit a five year high of a vacancy of 2.4%. Now, you know, that's still not quite high, I guess, when we're looking at the numbers, but we've been on average sitting uh within the ones for a really long period of time. Um, I think it's been sort of around that 1.3 to 1.5. so we certainly have you know, dr increased to that 2.4%.

But we've also seen annual rental growth slowed to 5.2 and advertised rental listings across the capital cities have now increased 8% year on year. So it just means that our rental conditions are also easing. But I think what I'd like to probably draw us back to is probably episode two or three again when we were chatting with Tim Lawless from Cotality, and he positioned it then right for us, Pete, that.

That that tenants or, renters were already at their affordability ceiling then. And and we're talking back in May when we were chatting with Tim. And I think that where we're starting to now see the softening is is this impact, right? Of the fact that those rents have gone to those kind of peak highs in all of the locations. and now the tenants are just saying we just simply cannot afford to pay that. And so they're sitting

**Peter Schravemade** (04:47)

Can't can't afford it. Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (04:49)

back and waiting and/or uh negotiating.

with their current landlords in terms of what weekly rent they should in fact be paying so they can stay. So yeah, I

**Peter Schravemade** (05:00)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (05:00)

think it's now started to have that effect that Tim forecasted many, many, many months ago. What's your take on that?

**Peter Schravemade** (05:06)

Yeah, yeah.

Yeah, well I think I I think absolutely you know, there's a lot of suburbs that rent rent can't go higher. I think we were looking at the Gold Coast a couple of episodes ago and and the median

**Kasey McDonald** (05:17)

Absolutely.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:18)

medium uh no, sorry, the the the what is it, the minimum wage s y yeah, the median rent sits

**Kasey McDonald** (05:23)

Yeah, the medium rent. Yeah. Well the medium rent was I think nine hundred and something.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:27)

yeah, it sits like within I think you had thirty dollars a a week left.

**Kasey McDonald** (05:33)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:33)

by the time you compared the two and it would that's just insane. That's like that's what some people are living off. And I obviously

**Kasey McDonald** (05:39)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:40)

in some areas I I don't think it can go much higher. South East Queensland here

**Kasey McDonald** (05:43)

No.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:43)

it's it's crazy. I I mean it it it can. It can to be honest, but we

**Kasey McDonald** (05:49)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (05:49)

we would see um mass homelessness. You know, actually getting people into a house would be incredibly difficult. And I I th I think, you know, you'd see

a lot of a lot of negative things start to happen in society

**Kasey McDonald** (06:01)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (06:01)

'cause when people are without home and shelter, other things are impacted their health, their well being, crime rates go up. you know, i there's this there's this huge knock on effect for not having a house. So I look I'm hoping I'm hoping that the the cost of living reduces. And that is rents, that is food, that is groceries, that's bills, that's electricity, that all of the things that we've been talking about. So

**Kasey McDonald** (06:23)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (06:24)

No, it'd be good to good to see that go down, but definitely there's no more I think he used the word elasticity in the rental market to raise the rents, yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (06:29)

Yes, he did. Yeah.

He did. Yeah. And look, I think some interesting stats that I'll just quickly share with our listeners today is you know the Perth supply is rising fast. And now we've certainly seen that market on on on a high peak for a really long time. There's certainly been in a growing space across both sales and rentals in the in the WA market space, but we're now seeing

That they went from uh, I think it was about 1900 four weeks ago on the market to now 2100. they're seeing, another 592 properties rented, but it was actually down uh from the same period last year at 697. So we certainly are seeing the Perth market cooling, and it has it the the stats and data from Cotality and the ABC article indicate that that's actually cooling the quickest, or it did in the last fortnight.

Which is interesting. But uh Queensland remains the exception, actually. we're still fairly tight here, and tenants are staying longer. Um, and that's been based on the data from the REIQ, actually, which shows throughout September. Now I know we're that's probably a few months earlier, but we're still sitting on average tenancies of about 21 months, where typically they're normally at 18 uh.5 months. So

The those stretching of those tenancies. So, to my point earlier, we've got tenants who are renegotiating to stay in their homes and whether that is just to slightly pay a little bit more so that they then don't have to have all of those additional costs that of course as well come with moving. But yeah, some interesting data coming out around the rental market, where it's easing and in what locations. So for those property managers.

listening and BDMs of course, make sure that you get across all of the data of what's going on in your local marketplace.

**Peter Schravemade** (08:15)

Hm. Yep. let's move on, because we've got a f we've got a few more for you here, but there's a December ten privacy deadline uh coming up, right? Uh

**Kasey McDonald** (08:24)

Mm-hmm. Yeah, definitely.

**Peter Schravemade** (08:27)

yeah. I I is is it it's around it it's around rental screening software, is that correct?

**Kasey McDonald** (08:33)

Yes, it is. Yeah. So uh I actually saw this article uh probably about a month ago. It was just a lead-in, actually, to say that on the 10th of December there was going to be some new privacy act rules coming in coming into play. And it was governing around I guess, decision making, but it was around that that automation. So it was within our software, and where of course we use particular AI functions of our software.

where it's supporting, I guess, making particular decisions for us, and then where we maybe analyze that and then present that. So there wasn't a lot of data at the time or a lot of a lot of information, I'd just say, about it. But this week the article has certainly come out and has expressed exactly what we might need to now be doing more specifically in our property management application process. and I know there's been some of our

Prop tech industry providers out there, Pete, within the rental space for applications that have been under scrutiny around particular elements as well. But it's basically saying computer program. And so what we need to consider here, guys, is that on the 10th of December, the law is saying that futuristic AI tools beard pointed out the legislation and explanatory memorandum explicitly explicitly covering.

Any pre-programmed rule-based computer program that's even an Excel spreadsheet, if you've got particular components in it that's doing analytics for you, that's going to calculate the suitability and a score rating that will either reject or put, you know, put that, I guess, renter into a certain field to say they may be suitable. andor it's basing it as well on the minimum income threshold.

So it's it's indicating that now we really need to take a look at what we've got written within our privacy act to ensure that we're not getting fines. Cause it's looking at significant fines here, um, where it may look at businesses that have got turnovers over three million dollars, where it's really going to dive in there to say, how and which are you actually making sure that you are not breaching privacy.

by having an automated computer program analyze your rental applications. I guess in a nutshell is what this is really saying, is that it wants the human, uh,

**Peter Schravemade** (10:52)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (10:53)

property manager to uh pick the most suitable tenant based on the information and not just put it into a score matching system. So some interesting stuff

**Peter Schravemade** (11:02)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (11:03)

coming out in the privacy space as well.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:06)

Yeah, yeah. Well I I'm finding it interesting that the government's own ex explanatory memorandum uses an Excel spreadsheet to calculate a

**Kasey McDonald** (11:12)

Yeah. Yeah, I know.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:14)

score. That's uh

**Kasey McDonald** (11:16)

yeah. When I read that it says even if you're using an Excel

spreadsheet, that's when I read it yesterday and I was like, hang on

**Peter Schravemade** (11:20)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (11:21)

a minute. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:22)

That's a sledge at the the at the property management industry if I've ever seen one. Probably un probably unintended, but

**Kasey McDonald** (11:26)

Yeah it is. Yeah, exactly.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:29)

let's let's move on. So you've got another story here. So New South Wales watchdog puts PMs in the firing line for twenty tw twenty six, twenty seven. Um I

**Kasey McDonald** (11:38)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:39)

I think this is around compliance and enforcement priorities, right? it that they're saying that they're targeting

**Kasey McDonald** (11:44)

Yeah, it is.

**Peter Schravemade** (11:46)

them.

**Kasey McDonald** (11:47)

Yes, absolutely. look, we'll start in New South Wales. So the New South Wales Fair Trading and State Consumer Watchdog formally unveiled that they're going to be looking at compliance and enforcement priorities, placing real estate agents and property managers squarely uh on the target list throughout 27.

Are following a rollout of the smart rental bonds. that's also um looking at domestic violence and the co-tenant notification rules, where the agents and landlords must notify the remaining co-tenant and specifically the pet rule. So that's allowing tenants to move in with a pet and keep it at the property while consent is considered. So in New South Wales throughout 2027, they're really going to be uh, I guess, holding.

us as agents and property managers, I guess, to the top standards of this compliance around these particular three rulings or legislation changes that have occurred. and in Queensland, it's going to be around the strata component. and what we actually saw, um, and it was in a domain article actually, that there was a couple that challenged their apartment building.

laws around pets and it banned owners and tenants from taking pets inside the building. And I think we touched on this if it wasn't last week, it was the week before around kind of the pets and in buildings and how stratas were looking at changing these. There was a little fluffy dog that wasn't allowed in, but in fact it actually was, I think, yeah. so it they're

**Peter Schravemade** (13:12)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (13:12)

looking at how do they, I guess, ban it, not ban it.

What does it actually mean? where are they actually allowed within I guess the strata complexes? So yeah, there's some things certainly coming. Um, well, I guess some more uh enforcements that the property managers need to be aware of. But I think, you know, for for Queensland property managers, it's just as common sense, I think, with around pets, but certainly for New South Wales.

Let's don't miss some of those deadlines in especially around the D B pieces. So that's the compliance

**Peter Schravemade** (13:38)

Yeah, well yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (13:41)

piece that they're gonna make enforceable, is that you must meet those deadlines. That is ex that is what the articles are indicating. So really, really str they're gonna get really strict on us, but I just find that I just don't know how they're going to make it enforceable, especially in New South Wales, in particular

**Peter Schravemade** (13:58)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (13:58)

with that piece of legislation. Yeah, it's gonna

**Peter Schravemade** (14:01)

Yep. Yep.

**Kasey McDonald** (14:02)

be tricky.

**Peter Schravemade** (14:03)

Yeah, I don't yeah, and I d I don't particularly like that New South Wales D V legislation. I that like it less that the that the Office of Fair Trading in New South Wales and isn't communicating with the REINSW over it. I I'm not sure that that's changed, but that was the

**Kasey McDonald** (14:15)

Exactly. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (14:17)

last time I heard heard about it. we were at the first national property management conference and and even then the agents didn't really know you know, it was a talking

**Kasey McDonald** (14:25)

No.

**Peter Schravemade** (14:25)

point in that

J w weren't sure what was going on. Um let's go on to Yeah. Let's

**Kasey McDonald** (14:30)

No, there's a lot of uncertainty. But yeah, look at that that's me

this week from the PM desk, Pete.

**Peter Schravemade** (14:36)

Thank you very much. And we'll move to the sales desk. I I don't know who has that. Not not but not particularly me. But I th I suppose the major story was the the article out in the Courier Mail. It was a bizarre article. now I don't know Phil Parker. Do you know Phil Parker?

**Kasey McDonald** (14:49)

No, I don't actually.

**Peter Schravemade** (14:51)

No. So I obviously a prolific auctioneer if he's poor you know, if he's he's he's been re responsible for fifty three thousand auctions. he had some he had some good points, I not

wasn't really sure why why this was a news story. So I'm not gonna I'm not gonna focus on it. But he did he did uh call out look at me agents, I guess was the the way he put it and and I don't I don't think we really like the you know these type of agents have you know they've always tended to be a storm and a teacup. They come and make a big announcement about how wonderful they are and then they disappear. you know, we had one in New South Wales at the start of the year that we we were all talking about

so he was calling that out, but he was also actually suggesting that he, you know, we should be looking at random drug tests for for real estate agents. And you know, I don't know, I don't know how you feel about this. I th I I would suggest that I think we're gonna be pretty much aligned on it. but but like it just seems weird that this industry would

I guess he's pointing to a larger drug culture and and I I am aware of that. There is a drug culture in this industry, but I I I mean, is does that mean that does that stop an agent from being effective at their duty? Like I've I've got to assume that if you're ahead of an agency and an agent turned up pinging or on coke or whatever it is that they're doing, y that would affect their performance and that would probably lead to them being terminated, even if they were uh

a good agent, but maybe not, I don't know. But w random drug tests seems to imply that what real estate agents do in their in the privacy of their own home is is suddenly the responsibility of of somebody else. And I'm not sure I agree with that. Now you were you and I are are not drug takers. We don't we we're not we're we're not we've I've never I've never touched drugs in my life and that that even includes pot and whatever else. But

So I look, it's not it's not me. Like I d I don't I don't like people doing it. I don't like that our industry's tarnished with it, but I can't say that I'm calling for random drug tests. That's seems to me to be a a step over the line. I don't know. Thoughts?

**Kasey McDonald** (17:05)

there's a drug culture across many elements, not just our industry. I mean, look at what's going on in the news still, in regards to Sydney Swans players in the AFL and, you know, all of those things that occur. And we've also got NRL players that get caught drink driving or on drugs and, you know, all of those different things, right? So I think from a cultural perspective, there seems to be a drug

I guess habit or a culture within Australia, regardless of what the industry is. Now, I appreciate in those professions, there is those randoms. but I I don't know. I just I feel like until it becomes such a point in time that it does then affect the way in which we do operate. you know, uh has it meant that someone's bought a house with someone under that influence and what

hasn't meant that the decision or the contract hasn't been negotiated in the same way. I don't know, right? Because we haven't been there to witness it. So yeah, I feel like it's a little bit of a.

**Peter Schravemade** (18:03)

But there

are protections. There are protections in play for that. we are a heavily regulated industry. So, you know, it's

**Kasey McDonald** (18:06)

absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, definitely.

**Peter Schravemade** (18:09)

to me it doesn't seem to be about performance. I I I think he wants surrender drug tests to clean up the industry and there'd be a lot of

**Kasey McDonald** (18:15)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (18:15)

us saying, actually, that would be really good. may maybe maybe that is a solution. But uh yeah, it just seems seems to be a bit of overreach. Like

**Kasey McDonald** (18:24)

Yeah, I just

**Peter Schravemade** (18:24)

I don't know.

**Kasey McDonald** (18:25)

yeah, I think yeah, I think maybe sort of I guess a way you know, has kind of come out about it, right? and and expressed I guess his views on it, has yeah, ha has probably given that that impression, I feel. But yeah, I think we've got regulations.

There's so many other industries that that look at this in different ways. But I think, you know, why really is he suggesting it? Is it a performance thing or is it not a performance thing? Is it just simply to clean up the industry? that I don't think was clear in his opinion. Hm.

**Peter Schravemade** (18:56)

Mm. Yeah.

Yep. Let's move on. I I can't see it happening, but you know, it'd be an interesting one then. I think I think it'd be it'd be very interesting if that was introduced.

**Kasey McDonald** (19:07)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (19:09)

look, there's portal wars in court. So um a judge

**Kasey McDonald** (19:11)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (19:11)

has ordered the REA group to prove its nine in ten buyers claim in a domain lawsuit. So there I don't know if you've seen this story, but REA

groups been ordered to hand over internal documents and underlying data previous flagship marketing claim that nine in ten buyers find their home on the platform. Now I I you know I I I think there are there are agents that that use this in their listing presentation, but Domain are ch challenging the accuracy and substantiation of the REA groups marketing campaign. I I I would too. I I don't I don't believe that that's correct. I

think a lot of people use realestate.com.au I think they are the benchmark in Australia. particularly now, I'd be I'd absolutely be questioning that. I have a strong belief that a lot of people are using artificial intelligence in the search for

**Kasey McDonald** (20:00)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (20:00)

a new home now. And so particularly right now, that I don't I don't believe nine in ten vendors actually do. And then there are areas like

Don't forget there are areas in Australia that don't use the REA group at all. Like

**Kasey McDonald** (20:14)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (20:14)

i it Canberra is a great example of a market that that has its own property portal inside it and or you know, in that in for that particular area. In Victoria, Domain is quite strong. in Western Australia, REWA has a a fairly

**Kasey McDonald** (20:27)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (20:28)

substantial profile there. So, you know, even if just thought of those three areas and the

l maybe the REA group doesn't have such dominance in that area. It makes that claim very difficult to understand. And then also, you know, with artificial intelligence now coming into the home search and no one's really talking about that, but it's definitely here. It's definitely been used. y I I wonder how what percentage of people are using artificial intelligence to find it. And and the crazy part about that is REA blocks AI from scraping its site.

So if you are using artificial intelligence to go to purchase a house, there is a very, very good chance you're going through domain, homely, or the agent's website directly. so, you know, interesting interesting times where if if fifty percent of people, as I suspect or more, are using AI in the home search, they're probably finding it through another platform. So I actually think domain has a very, very strong case here. but it

But ha if the REA group have it, then they I guess we're gonna find out soon, right?

**Kasey McDonald** (21:32)

Yeah,

definitely. Yeah, look, I think you know, we're probably already seeing with the listings kind of at their highest since twenty nineteen, the vendors would already be pushing back on the cost of marketing spend, right? so not only are we seeing those rates rising, but our values of our homes, you know, decreasing um and quickly uh that then to actually spend the money that's required uh to get it in front of the right types of buyers now.

yeah, I'm absolutely with you. I don't know that it's gonna be at those levels. maybe through those those peaks, they might have not had as a stronger claim, but certainly now, uh, you know, with properties sitting there, I don't understand how they could be getting those types of numbers out. But yeah, it'd be interesting to see what

**Peter Schravemade** (22:17)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (22:17)

comes out of this. When of course ACC have already been on REA's

case and back and right, and they're they're looking at them, right? And they're watching them. So very, very

**Peter Schravemade** (22:23)

Seems to be a Yep. Yep.

**Kasey McDonald** (22:28)

interesting.

**Peter Schravemade** (22:29)

Yeah, yeah. let's let's move on from that. I guess it's a watch this space anyway. the Bank of Mum and Dad. So this is a this is an interesting

**Kasey McDonald** (22:36)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (22:37)

one. So there's a string of alarming finance stories that have been published between Monday and Thursday, so the second of November to the fifth, exposing how the combination of falling property values, which is down eight point one percent across capital cities since March.

as per the ABC totality report that we were speaking about before. And Tuesday's fifth i interest rate hike, so to four point eight five, is blowing up a complex buyer finance structures. So th the there's a couple of parts to this. So the fifty thousand dollar risk for loan guarantors. So the in in R E B yesterday, um, they reported that property price falls exposed, fifty thousand K risk for loan guarantors. So that that's

**Kasey McDonald** (23:16)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (23:17)

effectively the bank of mum and dad, the parents who went

Ga guarantor on their low deposit home purchases in the in late twenty-five and twenty-six are now trapped in a negative equity where, they might have paid a million for the house. That's that's let you know, up fift now that's down five percent. so that's that's one, and that's leading to a fifty thousand dollar cash short shortfall if the child defaults, which is placing more pressure on. Do you remember how Elbo came out and did the whole it's those terrible older generation? Well, they're actually funding a lot of people

**Kasey McDonald** (23:46)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (23:46)

getting into it.

And now they're

**Kasey McDonald** (23:47)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (23:48)

trapped as a guarantor on a on negative cash shortfall. So that that's one article.

**Kasey McDonald** (23:52)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (23:53)

Very, very interesting. the bridging loan nightmare is another one. So bridging loans that it's it's kind of a a gamble that puts buyers in debt nightmare. So these are the upgraders who bought first using high interest bridging finance, assuming

**Kasey McDonald** (24:07)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (24:07)

their existing home would sell in 21 days, but they're now watching their own h home sit unsold for the past 39 plus days while values drop.

another very, very interesting squeeze on the market, one I I I I'd heard about the the Bank of Mum and Dad, but that's a s that's a secondary one in in two days. And then we've got this other article that came out overnight. that there are 50 Victorian suburbs locked out. And now what they're what property buzz is saying is that the RBA's two most rac recent rate hikes have wiped fifty-five Victorian suburbs off the list of places that an average borrower could

could afford. So this is statistical, but you know, they're saying that Melbourne i e even even with the softening of inner Melbourne auctions, a house in Fitzroy for nine hundred and fifty thousand dollars is almost unheard of.

**Kasey McDonald** (24:55)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (24:55)

So look, they're three three articles that kind of should sound alarm across I would hope the federal government's dashboard to that this is this is not looking pretty. Like I'd the

the the news, if you just do a a look at where the property market's going, I I've heard all of the real estate agents, Kasey, in the industry, that have been here a long time ago, we've had it good for six years. it's, you know, we understand that we're going to go through a tough time. I I I genuinely haven't seen one like like we're in at the moment. So um I'm I'm I'm not as buoyant as some of those industry influences are in saying, come on, toughen up.

take your cup of cement, it's all gonna be right. th this is this is actually looking really bad from a a a a a a shelter, a home perspective. So I I don't know that you know I th I think you're gonna have to sound out buyers that come through your open homes more. You're gonna really have to qualify as to whether they are fiscally sound in order to purchase. You you got got some thoughts?

**Kasey McDonald** (26:03)

Yeah, look, I think that that increase is getting passed on, right? You know, I got the the fantastic email yesterday. so you know, even for us, that's an extra a hundred odd a fortnight or a month. that's, you know, that's coming, right? So like it and

**Peter Schravemade** (26:16)

It's crazy. It's crazy how much it matter matters.

**Kasey McDonald** (26:18)

and then it's you see NAB is saying we're you know, getting rid of all of our people. You've got Westpac saying that they haven't made enough profit. I'm not sure how.

When, they're getting all this extra interest. But I think more importantly, it's it it hasn't actually done what the government wanted it to do with these changes and these reforms. In fact, it has done the complete opposite, which is

**Peter Schravemade** (26:41)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (26:41)

what we said from the beginning and we continue to bang on about, right? So it's now meaning that with just because the property prices are starting to soften and they're coming down, and in some locations, we've seen property prices drop over a hundred thousand in six months.

That still is not allowing them to be affordable because we have seen these five rate increases. So for those that are then consuming, well, what kind of deposit do I still need? You're going to need that 20% as an example. Or if you're looking at mom and dad now, mom and dad might have to go into negative that that'll go into negative equity straight away, which is what that's just kind of sharing. But they don't have enough money. They're needing to save more. But yet the affordability now, because of the interest rate hike.

they they still can't get into the market. So it is absolutely done the complete opposite. And in some cases they now need to look at how

**Peter Schravemade** (27:33)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (27:34)

do I come up with an extra twenty K. Um, and then again, if we don't if this inflation doesn't come down and they're forecasting it's not going to until probably the end of next year, what is this really going to mean for our property market? So yeah, it's not looking good, I don't think.

**Peter Schravemade** (27:53)

No, no, there's a I I'd love to I'd love to give the listeners some hope, but uh

**Kasey McDonald** (27:57)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (27:57)

I'm in agreement on that. let's move on, hopefully to something more positive. we got place, a franchise. I I don't see them in the news very much these days, but

**Kasey McDonald** (28:06)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (28:07)

they've launched a 200 home auction blitz blitz, right?

**Kasey McDonald** (28:10)

Okay.

**Peter Schravemade** (28:11)

So I think it's w one week after Apollo data showed three and four.

Brisbane auctions failing under the hammer. So that's only a a clearance rate of twenty-five percent. Brisbane place agents doubled down on auctions yesterday, launching a massive two hundred home auction blitz. So I don't I don't I actually don't mind this. I think I think this is a fantastic idea by those guys. I d I don't know them very well, but like in in the midst of all of the doom and gloom that we're hearing, these guys are going, well, screw you, market, we're gonna sell these anyway. So

**Kasey McDonald** (28:42)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (28:42)

And people have to transact, they still have to transact home. So two

**Kasey McDonald** (28:46)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (28:46)

hundred a two hundred auction blitz, it'll be really interesting how how that goes. But I I think I think this is a great idea. What what are your thoughts?

**Kasey McDonald** (28:54)

Mm-hmm.

Yeah, look, I think you know, it's out of the box thinking in terms of, you know, what do we need to do here, right? We're in a slowing market, we're not transacting as quickly. there are buyers out there, they've been sitting waiting. And so why don't we what let's think of something to get them all into a room, bring all the properties there, and see if we can get some results and what that actually looks like and maybe get some activity right and some positive activity happening back in the market. So well done to, you know, the place estate agents that are looking to do this.

I also I actually saw last night, and and they always do this every year, but the Ray White Surface Group, Surface Paradise Group, they always do something similar every single year at the same time. And that auction,

**Peter Schravemade** (29:35)

Right.

**Kasey McDonald** (29:35)

yeah, they're they're doing something similar, but they've actually always done it. and they bring everything on this one weekend in the room to get, you know, the results. So

it's interesting that we've got that sort of happening from a Gold Coast perspective and then a Brisbane market perspective, potentially I don't know if it's the same weekend, but nice to see that agents are thinking, what do we need to do to get some really positive activity happening?

**Peter Schravemade** (29:58)

Yeah, I really like it. I'll I'll go from there to a story. Like I I I th I think that's a fan fantastic initiative. I'll

**Kasey McDonald** (30:05)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (30:06)

go from there to a story. so this is a I guess it's a marketing story. It's out from REB that that came out the other day. That there's a marketing specialist that is warning agents that chasing TikTok reels or algorithms with flashy

viral comedy skits is actually destroying their local listing pipeline. And this is an interesting one 'cause I've seen a few I think we had a marketing campaign on here and you were like, she's getting lots of c clicks and I said, Yeah, but are they the right ones? And

**Kasey McDonald** (30:33)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (30:34)

and and I think this article actually speaks to that because, you know, if you're getting half a million views from teenagers who are interstate, that

then trains your algorithm to stop showing your content to the 300 homeowners in your actual core postcode. So what what that person's saying it's actually quality over quantity. So don't go chasing the viral it's it's actually something very interesting. in in it it's interesting to me because I'm here in America and a lot of the influencers and coaches over here will point to their Instagram and go, We've got that many followers. But

**Kasey McDonald** (31:06)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (31:06)

nobody actually bothers to go through a vet actu are these guys buyers or they sellers?

**Kasey McDonald** (31:10)

Yeah, who's engaging,

yeah. Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (31:11)

Um, who who is engaging? Are they

are they is it is it two and a half million Indians who have no impact on the American market? And I remember it some time ago, Jacinta Allen, the the former premier of Victoria made news because overnight her Instagram g account went from X to whatever, I forget the number,

**Kasey McDonald** (31:31)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (31:31)

but it was it was like a hundred thousand odd people joined and so I'm like, you know

Yeah, I th I I actually think that's it's something that we don't discuss enough. the quality of of the people that we're hitting in our social media campaigns. So yeah, I I I think that's that very important.

**Kasey McDonald** (31:47)

Yeah, I agree actually, because I'm like,

I'm not on I'm not on TikTok, right? But of course my teenage stepchildren are. And so again,

**Peter Schravemade** (31:55)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (31:56)

I I kind of agree here. It's about the right type of audience that you're attracting. Now, don't get me wrong, there might be a home in a particular area that is maybe s more suited to a demographic that you feel is going to be on TikTok. So go for it, right? But is it about what what what I guess platform

really might be the best way if you're utilizing social to do so and to get it out there. Where are you going

**Peter Schravemade** (32:21)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (32:22)

to get the right type of or the correct type of engagement on which type

**Peter Schravemade** (32:26)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (32:26)

of platform? Yeah. All of us oldies are on Facebook. So if you've got the older generation, right? You go to Facebook. Yeah. Probably the next one, you go

**Peter Schravemade** (32:32)

So it just

**Kasey McDonald** (32:33)

to Instagram and then the real youngies go to TikTok. Isn't that how it works? uh Well, like,

**Peter Schravemade** (32:37)

Just for the record, I didn't say anything about your age on that particular occasion.

**Kasey McDonald** (32:41)

you know,

I thought I would just add it in this week, considering you always seem to have a dig at me about my age, considering what what aren't you actually older than me? Who?

**Peter Schravemade** (32:50)

I might be, but you know, when you look this good Whatever.

yeah, well let's not get into age then.

**Kasey McDonald** (32:54)

If you if you want to sell your house to Pete, don't do it on TikTok. No.

**Peter Schravemade** (32:59)

Oh I won't I won't be seeing you there, but you could you could try.

**Kasey McDonald** (33:01)

Hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:04)

let's let's move on. So this is this is kind of our our last major story for the day.

Well, it's it's probably the biggest one. I I I

**Kasey McDonald** (33:12)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:12)

actually can't believe I haven't heard this before. but this surface this week actually I had some it was in the news this week, but I had some there are some groups that social media groups that I'm involved in, obviously not TikTok, but that have been talking about this particular lady for a bit. Her name is Venetia Story, I think S T

**Kasey McDonald** (33:31)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:32)

O D R Y.

**Kasey McDonald** (33:33)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:34)

And I I'm I'm I'm actually quite

My mind is boggled looking at this. So the the the what happened this week is she's been barred for life for operating, which is like that's a that's a that's

**Kasey McDonald** (33:45)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (33:46)

a fairly hectic hectic outcome. She's been barred for life for practicing in real estate, right? So i it went to QCAT, she got a lifetime real estate ban, and th the way it went is I believe she took over her from her father's property management.

roll rent roll.

**Kasey McDonald** (34:04)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (34:05)

her father John's story. D do you do you know this man? I I've never heard of them.

**Kasey McDonald** (34:10)

No, so I think he used to go by Anthony. it yeah,

**Peter Schravemade** (34:14)

Anthony, yep.

**Kasey McDonald** (34:16)

yeah. So no, I don't know him, but

**Peter Schravemade** (34:18)

And and he

**Kasey McDonald** (34:19)

yeah, he had he his real estate was called Anthony Story Real Estate. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (34:25)

Right. And he

he came to ill health or his health declined in two thousand seventeen, eighteen. He passed away. Sadly passed away in two thousand eighteen. Venetia, I I believe her name is, she took over his property management business and changed it to Story Real Estate Proprietary Limited. And the

**Kasey McDonald** (34:43)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (34:44)

Office of Fair Trading began investigating her almost straight away after an audit flag to trust shortfall. and then then there was a QCAT.

Member Oliver's decision. Well, I don't even know what that is. Do you know what that is? QCAT

**Kasey McDonald** (34:59)

No no.

**Peter Schravemade** (35:01)

member Oliver's I think he's the name of the guy that did it. Yes, he

**Kasey McDonald** (35:04)

Right.

**Peter Schravemade** (35:04)

is. so the the QCAT decision, yes,

**Kasey McDonald** (35:06)

he was the adjudicator, he was the tribunal quip member. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (35:09)

yeah, he it revealed that she operated and opened a trust account and collected rent before her company even held a corporate license, which is a big no no. But

**Kasey McDonald** (35:17)

Interesting. Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (35:19)

but not not lifetime banable.

She then drew a flat six thousand dollars a month out of the trust account for herself, regardless of actual commissions earned, claiming that that's how things had been done. Then she overcharged landlords by adding ten percent GST on top of commissions that the Form Six appointments said were already GST inclusive. She failed to lodge bonds within forty-two days, failed to bank rent on time, kept no auditability books or monthly reconciliations.

And didn't know she needed to appoint a relief licensee when absent for over 30 days. Fifty nearly $55,000 was paid from the claim fund, later largely recovered from the frozen account, and then she was also convicted of intentionally obstructing the court appointed receiver. now that you're lucky this this was 2018. Yep, and then after

**Kasey McDonald** (36:12)

That it was all in one year. Yeah. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (36:16)

seven years of appeals, QCAT.

Permanently banned her for life because she lacked insight and was likely to re-offend. Wow. Well that is that is just crazy. But then then part two. So there's a part two for this. She's declared a rare vexatious litigant. So after twenty-four cases in seven years, there's a the story verse Parkin and

**Kasey McDonald** (36:42)

Yeah, that's what I mean. Like that that

what you just shared was only happening in one year. that's what I mean. The story gets better because of how many cases across such a long period

**Peter Schravemade** (36:49)

Wow, better or

**Kasey McDonald** (36:51)

of time, right?

**Peter Schravemade** (36:52)

better or worse. So rather than cooperating, Story went to war with the courts after being made bankrupt in March twenty two. A three judge full federal courtbench took the rare step of declaring her a vexatious litigant, labeling the undischarged bankrupt as an indef indef indefe indefatigable indefatigable lit litigant. basically

**Kasey McDonald** (37:17)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (37:17)

She's gonna keep suing you. After

telling twenty four separate proceedings in seven years, including nineteen decisions since twenty twenty one. Nineteen.

**Kasey McDonald** (37:24)

Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (37:27)

Who is this lady? Against the Office of Fair Trading, the Business Licensing Authority, the police and her bankruptcy trustees, while accusing judges of bias and fraud. The full

**Kasey McDonald** (37:37)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (37:37)

court ruled her filings were why what is that word?

**Kasey McDonald** (37:40)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (37:41)

Misconceived. Yeah, it it it this is it. Then there's part three.

**Kasey McDonald** (37:46)

Yeah. Well it keeps going, that's what I mean. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (37:46)

So that's part two. W wait y wait,

but wait, there's more. Hold my beer. So the QCAT Lifetime Ban, the Vexatious Litigant, and part three is she's stripped as an executor of her dad's two point two million Tuong estate and commenting on the blog. So under her father's will, Venetia was appointed executor and left a two thirds share of his house on Brosley Road Tuong, valued at between one point five and two point two.

With her sisters Amber and Sweden left one sixth each, she transferred the property into her name as executor and then stalled distributing the estate for over six and a half years, blaming her QCAT trust account battles. While two thirds share vested in her bankruptcy trustee, David Lewis Clout, both the sub both the Sucr Supreme Court and the and QCAT dismissed her appeals and revoked her probate so an independent solicitor could finally administer the estate incredibly

The day after succession law blog Airs and Successors wrote up the Court of Appeal loss, Venetia Story appeared in the WordPress comment section under her own name, declaring, I am the party in this article. There is a high court appeal on foot. I don't I don't know where to go with that. I

**Kasey McDonald** (39:04)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (39:05)

I feel as though the industry is better off

**Kasey McDonald** (39:08)

Totally agree. yeah, that's a lot. And I guess, you know, there's been so many different cases at at each point in time. I guess my question probably out there is why was she not suspended uh from operating or her business closed far earlier than seven years' time, seven years later, um, you know, with more more damage done. I and I understand they, you know, went through different investigations and different cases, but I think with so many.

being heard uh across those years. I'm just really surprised that we didn't suspend her first of all. but yeah we're we're

**Peter Schravemade** (39:41)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (39:41)

at this decision today. And I think the industry is far better off to not have people like her operating.

**Peter Schravemade** (39:47)

Well,

after seven years, I'll just read this out again. After seven years, QCAT

**Kasey McDonald** (39:50)

Mm. Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (39:53)

permanently banned her for life because she lacked insight and was likely to reoffend. that's that's vicious. That is vicious. Lacked insight. I I d I

**Kasey McDonald** (39:58)

Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (40:03)

I don't know, you know, I'm not gonna summarise what they're saying 'cause I don't really want her to come see me, so I'll just leave it

**Kasey McDonald** (40:08)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (40:08)

at what's in the article. Let's move on. Three

**Kasey McDonald** (40:11)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (40:11)

agents charged with kidnapping and robbing a trade.

**Kasey McDonald** (40:14)

Right. Really? Wow. Where did this come from?

**Peter Schravemade** (40:15)

What? What? Yep. Yeah.

Well, it's it's a real estate business reported yesterday these agents are facing fourteen years in jail over alleged aggravated kidnapping and robbing robbing robbery. On a shocking court case which three real estate agents and a taxi driver have been charged with aggreg aggravated kidnapping, assault and robbery. The court heard a tradesman was allegedly lured to a residential property under the guise of quoting carrying out maintenance work.

Where three agents and the driver ambushed, punched, kicked, choked, and threatened to kill h him and his family and robbed him. All alleged. All alleged at this stage. But um

**Kasey McDonald** (40:54)

Well yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (40:55)

what what what the heck? I leave the country and it falls to pieces, Kasey. What can I say?

**Kasey McDonald** (41:01)

Wow, but you there's an update as well, Pete, to like I c wow, I'm just

**Peter Schravemade** (41:05)

Is there?

**Kasey McDonald** (41:05)

I actually don't have any words to that, but there's an update to that. You remember the arsonist case of the real estate agency that

**Peter Schravemade** (41:10)

Yeah. Yep.

**Kasey McDonald** (41:12)

um on the Gold Coast. So the update to that is

**Peter Schravemade** (41:14)

Yeah, and office was set on fire.

**Kasey McDonald** (41:16)

that office was set on fire. Yeah. So the update to that as well is that the police have now laid additional charges against the alleged arsonist, including sexual assault, rape, drug possession, and theft. So

**Peter Schravemade** (41:27)

Oh

**Kasey McDonald** (41:27)

was a little bit more

**Peter Schravemade** (41:27)

my gosh.

**Kasey McDonald** (41:28)

involved in I guess the story behind that arsonist attack on the real estate office as well. So yeah, wow. But I actually don't I don't even have any words for that first one that you shared. I'm just I'm that's what I mean. Like

**Peter Schravemade** (41:41)

Wha what is going on there? That's gotta there's gotta be some

un

**Kasey McDonald** (41:45)

Yeah, there's definitely something obviously further that we're

**Peter Schravemade** (41:47)

Well

**Kasey McDonald** (41:49)

that's not been exposed as and shared as a part of that

**Peter Schravemade** (41:51)

Well.

**Kasey McDonald** (41:52)

story. But yeah, if if it's if it's true,

**Peter Schravemade** (41:53)

Well, we'll keep it we'll keep an eye on it.

**Kasey McDonald** (41:55)

very, very shocking behavior. Terrible. Don't condone it at all.

**Peter Schravemade** (41:58)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (41:59)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (41:59)

No, no, not at all. let's move on. So the this the Fair Work Ombudsman upholds the sacking

**Kasey McDonald** (42:05)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (42:05)

of two hundred and fifty thousand dollar CBA lending exec over s secret a hundred and ninety thousand dollar referral a web. th is the first story in this section. I've got two of them. So uh

**Kasey McDonald** (42:16)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (42:16)

the way this this goes, I think Sydney this week reported by MPA on Tuesday, Fair Work Commission dep deputy president.

Gerard Boyce upheld the dismissal dismissal of a senior Commonwealth Bank home lending executive on a two hundred and fifty thousand dollar base salary plus two hundred thousand dollar bonus potential after a speak up whistleblower probe

**Kasey McDonald** (42:38)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (42:38)

uncovered his secret dealings with an accredited broker figure referred to as Hugo. Under I don't under

**Kasey McDonald** (42:43)

Hugo, right. Hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (42:46)

CBA's referral source program.

real estate agents, accounts and lawyers can earn commissions for referring loans, but mortgage brokers and builders are strictly banned and investigators found that two accredited referrals using financials from the accountants directly referred twenty nine home loan applications to the exec while funneling

**Kasey McDonald** (43:04)

Uh

**Peter Schravemade** (43:05)

eighty one thousand and sixty one thousand and forty eight from five

**Kasey McDonald** (43:08)

Wow.

**Peter Schravemade** (43:09)

borrowers to to Hugo, who are client identified as their mortgage broker.

and and he yeah, so he's been he's been fired. he's been sacked, I think. Um

**Kasey McDonald** (43:21)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (43:21)

but the like I don't know I I always knew like there are referral pro programs in place, right? But y they

**Kasey McDonald** (43:27)

Hm. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (43:28)

they require in Queensland they require disclosure. I I would assume that that's the same in New South Wales, right?

**Kasey McDonald** (43:36)

Yeah, it yeah, I I would suggest that it's very similar around most states. I definitely know it's Queensland and New South Wales that there is that disclosure around any additional rebate that you get, for whatever

**Peter Schravemade** (43:48)

Mm.

**Kasey McDonald** (43:49)

reason, you need to actually I mention that, both from a sales and a rental perspective.

**Peter Schravemade** (43:54)

Yep. And and the the next article is a word of warning. So

**Kasey McDonald** (43:58)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (43:59)

a one million dollar TikTok complaint bill. This is um so this this one's yeah, yeah, it is. This one's

**Kasey McDonald** (44:02)

Okay. Back to TikTok again, huh? Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:07)

from Nine News and the property buzz. a frustrated home buyer, I'm gonna have an attempt at his name,

**Kasey McDonald** (44:13)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:14)

Gervinda Paul Singh, who took to TikTok

**Kasey McDonald** (44:16)

Mm. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:17)

to air complaints about his home builder.

has been left roughly one million out of pocket after a string of defamation and court rulings went against him. So he was he was found to like it's it's a basically a name and shame, right?

**Kasey McDonald** (44:30)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:30)

Um whereby uh the the the guy's taken to TikTok and he's had a go at a a home builder and the home builder has said that none of that is true. Let's find out in court and lo and behold, I hope he got a lot of clicks because he's going to need it to

**Kasey McDonald** (44:44)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:44)

pay for

**Kasey McDonald** (44:45)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (44:46)

um what happened. but

yeah, it it is it is very interesting too like, you know, even just i in in doing this podcast, we have to always use alleged unless, you know, uh things like that. You just can't go around saying stuff about people if it's you know, not true and hoping that that they're not gonna they're

**Kasey McDonald** (45:03)

Yeah, exactly.

**Peter Schravemade** (45:05)

not gonna kick up about it. But anyway, anyway.

**Kasey McDonald** (45:08)

I know, I always

have to make sure you mind your Ps and Q's. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (45:11)

do you do, is

that what you're here for? Very good.

**Kasey McDonald** (45:15)

Keeping you in line, right? um absolutely. Absolutely. Cause I think that a little bit of doom and gloom

**Peter Schravemade** (45:17)

Yeah, yeah, apparently. Should should we move should we move to our field Good Fridays? Yeah, c well I think we need it after after today.

**Kasey McDonald** (45:28)

again, Trey, right? Do you know what, right? Like we're gonna talk about the first one because of course it was my favorite show, as you keep saying, right? But I uh

**Peter Schravemade** (45:35)

Did you watch it? Did you actually watch it?

**Kasey McDonald** (45:37)

I did actually watch it. and I do you know what?

**Peter Schravemade** (45:40)

Ca I can't get

through an episode.

**Kasey McDonald** (45:42)

Really? No, but did you not watch the auctions? No, you didn't. Right. Okay. So

**Peter Schravemade** (45:45)

No, no, I never do. And I no.

**Kasey McDonald** (45:47)

yes, Ryan King, yes, on TV. You looked 12, buddy, right? But my God, he actually did steal the show. Like he did,

**Peter Schravemade** (45:55)

Titty.

**Kasey McDonald** (45:56)

like he actually did really well. He did so good. And and there's no disrespect to, you know, the more mature and experienced auctioneers that were also on the show that of course did amazing jobs.

But he just had

**Peter Schravemade** (46:10)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (46:10)

a a youthful energy about him. and yeah. Kudos to you, buddy. Well done. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (46:16)

well done. Good on him. So

**Kasey McDonald** (46:17)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (46:18)

uh am I understanding it correctly, Scotty Cam took the piss out of him, did he? He said he looks twelve.

**Kasey McDonald** (46:21)

Yeah, he

said and said because he was doing house five and said, my god, Taylor and Rick, who's your auctioneer? He looks twelve, right? And they were like, No, no, no, he's good, like, don't worry about it. and yeah, I think kind of then afterwards, with the result that he also was able to achieve for them, Scotty Cam might have ate his words a little. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Very very, very good. So yeah, I think he did a great

**Peter Schravemade** (46:41)

Ah, well that that's fantastic. What a legend. Um Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (46:48)

job. Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (46:50)

Big shout out to the REIQ Awards. We were we were both there. everyone everyone was a winner in my in my books.

**Kasey McDonald** (46:57)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (46:58)

Um but yeah, I think there's two that I'd like to single out. The I was lucky enough to present an award to the Tenancy Skills Institute um

**Kasey McDonald** (47:06)

Mm.

**Peter Schravemade** (47:07)

for for winning the Innovation Award. And that that's fantastic. They're a not for profit. The their their software doesn't cost anything to use. Like this is a social good software. So

I I was I was so the all of the finalists in that category were amazing, but I was so happy for these guys because that you know, I that's been a labor of love for those guys for years. So you know, well done to them them. It's really good to see how excited they were. I don't know, do you have a takeaway from there? I was also I think I was also a big fan of McGrath North Lakes taking out the REIQ

**Kasey McDonald** (47:38)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (47:39)

community co contribution trophy.

I I think I think that's outstanding and couldn't have gone to a better pair. David, if I know listens to us sometimes.

**Kasey McDonald** (47:49)

Mm-hmm.

**Peter Schravemade** (47:49)

but yeah, they've they've done so well that office as well in the community championship.

**Kasey McDonald** (47:53)

Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (47:53)

And also the REB had awards. Were you at that? Did you go to the R.E.B. Awards?

**Kasey McDonald** (47:56)

No, uh

wasn't at the REB awards. But yeah, just to close out the REIQ, just, congratulations as well to the Kollosche team being entered into the Hall of Fame. you know, I've had the privilege of working or, you know, having I guess a business relationship and doing some work and meeting Michael Kollosche over many, many years, at at events, but also within his four walls and a a really great business and the

The the culture when you walk in that door is just absolutely unbelievable. so well done to everyone involved and the and the Kollosche business.

**Peter Schravemade** (48:32)

Yeah, yeah. it's a a pretty fantastic. Yeah, it's a a longevity recognition as well, right? Um Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (48:38)

Mm. Yeah, definitely. Yeah. And certainly on the luxury high end, right? Because I, you know, a

majority of what they're selling is in the tens of millions of dollars stock. And so, you know, the longevity to be able to continue to do that, you know, with the I guess experien the co the customer experience and the and that culture that he also um brings to the business is is really amazing.

**Peter Schravemade** (49:00)

Yeah, I probably should mention as well big shout out to the Brewer family. I know if I was Peter Brewer I'd be incredibly proud of Lauren's achievement in becoming the the young REIQ board member. obviously deserved it it's it I I like I don't know if it's nostalgia, but I like the fact that someone's child chooses to follow in their footsteps in an industry and that's not a shout out to my kids, but it it it is it is really good to see those generations coming through because

Yeah, Lauren, I've known Peter for for years, but it's really good to it's been great to meet Lauren and see the impact that she's had on the industry as she comes through. So congratulations. and the name I was after McGraw Northwakes was David and Laura. So Laura Valenti is also a female director of the board of at the REIQ and they won the community champions award. So well done to McGrath North Lakes.

I have no other stories for you, Kasey, but I'm I'm so glad we finished on a high because

**Kasey McDonald** (49:56)

Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (49:56)

today that was a heavy that was a heavy episode.

**Kasey McDonald** (50:00)

It was, it

was indeed. Yes. Yes.

**Peter Schravemade** (50:03)

what have you got on for the weekend?

**Kasey McDonald** (50:05)

look, I think sun's shining here. it's nice and warm. So I actually think it might be nice to enjoy the pool. Uh sit back, relax, you know? Uh yeah, that's it, right? Yeah.

**Peter Schravemade** (50:13)

Sun's out, guns out. Fair enough. I've got

the I've got the N A R NXT. I'm actually looking forward to seeing two hundred plus odd exhibitors here. So that opens up tomorrow. I'll be walking the halls and seeing what kind of innovation is coming through in the American uh landscape today. And

**Kasey McDonald** (50:32)

All right.

**Peter Schravemade** (50:33)

yeah, meeting with I I spent the night with the Nevada Board of Realtors last night and

Georgia Board of Realtors I met. we've got a f got a few more meetings over here. So it'd be interesting to see how that plays out over the the week that's there. And then I'll I'll be back in time for Tech Fest in Perth at the end of next week. So it's jumping around a bit. But wherever you are this weekend, whatever you're doing, hope you're gonna have a great weekend. I hope you it's a successful one and it's happy hunting. right, Kasey?

**Kasey McDonald** (51:03)

Yes, happy hunting, happy listing, selling, renting, whatever it is that you're up to this weekend. hopefully we get some buyers out there who are happy to dig into their pockets, right? And the banks will loan to them. So let's hope we get some positive results in the market starting to come through. but

**Peter Schravemade** (51:20)

Yeah.

**Kasey McDonald** (51:21)

I think that's a wrap for us on Friday the 5th or the 6th of November, on before the weekend. Got the date right.